Red Truths
Nov 1, 2013 16:28:55 GMT 12
Post by Cloud on Nov 1, 2013 16:28:55 GMT 12
Yasu is indeed in play.
The culprit did not escape the shed using the window.
Natsuhi is not a victim.
Maria, George and Jessica are in the cousins' room.
The keys in the shed are the keys from the servants' room.
The paint [used on the doors] is from the garden shed.
There is a living breathing person still within the cousins' room as we speak.
The room the first victims are in has been sealed with a chain lock.
This chain lock has been sealed by the culprit.
Shannon is dead.
However, Shannon was not murdered.
Shannon did not commit suicide.
Shannon did not die in an accident.
Eva has no possession of any key whatsoever.
The window of the cousins' room has been closed and locked from the inside.
There are absolutely no accomplices.
The body in the VIP Room as of this moment is the real body of Natsuhi.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has appeared in front of the detective.
The culprit has moved bodies.
Natsuhi's body is still holding all her limbs. Quite nicely actually, very little leakage if you ask me. Fine craftsmanship.
The servants heard several things, why else would they be in the kitchen?
The servants found in the kitchen did not leave the kitchen during the murders of the men.
Before any questions are asked - yes, the servants found in the kitchen were in the kitchen to begin with during the murders of the men. This includes Nanjo.
Drugs - defined as a medicinal or intoxicating item considered neither food nor drink - have not been used at all during the course of this game.
At the start of this game there were exactly 20 people. Now, there are 13 people on the island of Rokkenjima.
Shannon has no corpse.
Natsuhi is not Beatrice.
Please, I demand you define the term "The Other Beatrice."
Kinzo does not represent anyone, he is a person.
Sakutarou does not represent George.
Everything else may stand.
Eva was not the first to solve the Riddle.
Rosa has not solved the riddle.
As of this moment, the stakes as they appeared during the fight scene do not have anything to do with neither a cause of death nor a murder weapon.
This is a story about the bond between mothers and their children.
Rosa: "I love my daughter, Maria so much. I would never harm her like this, maybe I ruined her image of me, maybe I looked like a black witch to her, but I would kill to ensure her happiness..."
Eva: "George... I never should have pushed you as much as I did. I truly loved you... I never would have wanted something like this to happen to you."
Kyrie: "Battler... I have never loved you and I truly wish you died instead of my own child 18 years ago."
The killer has not once been in disguise
As of the end of Turn Three GB, there are 8 people on the island of Rokkenjima.
The dead body identified as Shannon was not Kinzo.
The detective certainly did lay eyes on the keys in the shed.
Kyrie's death was not faked.
You have far more than three possible people to suspect to be the detective.
The body identified as the corpse of Shannon was not one of the servants in disguise.
Kyrie's cause of death was not killed by a stab wound.
The servants, with the exception of Kanon, are all dead.
There is one detective in every game, this player will live until the end of the game. Everything that is seen and observed by the detective is regarded as absolute and indisputable truth, the detective may be revealed by the GM. The Detective cannot be the true culprit.
I have provided the perspectives of more than 3 people:
Shannon
Kanon
Beatrice
Rosa
Eva
Natsuhi
Krauss
Sakutarou
Kyrie
There was a corpse in Shannon's clothing.
Kyrie was not killed from the outside.
Kanon is not a servant anymore. It has been stated for a very long time that his employed - Kinzo - is dead. I am of course referring to the original Kinzo Ushiromiya whose death was revealed at the start of this game. Until the death of Krauss, the only servant was Gohda, having been employed by him.
The corpse [identified as Shannon] was not one of the cousins.
I have already stated outright that Battler is not the only person who can be detective.
Rosa has been with the group whenever Battler has investigated crime scenes, her perspective doesn't need to be shown, it just needs to be said that everything Battler has seen, Rosa has seen also.
The detective is in Kuwadorian and they did hear the gunshot that killed Kyrie.
The servants have not upheld duties of a servant as evidenced by their disregard of bringing canned food to the family and their tailing of the party to Kuwadorian.
The corpse is Shannon's Clothes was a real body which really was dead. However, since before the beginning of this game, the body has lost its name.
Nanjo was seen by the detective outside the cousins room (the chained room where Jessica's body was seen) during the investigation of the first twilight (the time period where the survivors attempted and failed to get into the room and the garden shed).
Hideyoshi, Krauss and Rudolf are dead. Their corpses are in the VIP Room.
They all died in the second game board phase.
Krauss was sleeping peacefully in his room at the time of the murders.
Battler fell asleep in the parlour exactly as he said to Shannon. Whilst he was awake and waiting before falling asleep he was engrossed in a murder mystery story known as "Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni.
Eva was also asleep during the first twilight.
Natsuhi was in the VIP Room during all twilights from 2 onwards (as of this meta phase and with the possible exception of her own death as it occurred on the game board)
Natsuhi is dead.
Mammon has nothing to do with Natsuhi.
Eva was conscious as of current events depicted within the game board.
Eva is not wounded.
Someone solved the riddle before Eva. This was not Rosa however.
"Ange" is not one of the cousins.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has been seen by the detective throughout the course of this game.
Natsuhi was not stabbed to death.
The black witch has not solved the riddle.
Mammon is not a murder weapon.
Natsuhi was seen by the detective after the first twilight.
Natsuhi did not die of injuries.
Natsuhi was not poisoned.
The culprit did not solve the riddle.
The corpse of "Shannon" has no name. The corpse lost it's name before the start of the game.
Natsuhi is still Natsuhi.
The body in Shannon's clothes has lost it's entire name. It once had a name but upon the body's death, it's name has been moved.
Natsuhi did not solve the riddle.
The bomb has not gone off.
Natsuhi appeared in front of the detective before the second twilight.
I'd like to note that actions prior to the first twilight do not have be caused by the culprit i.e Kinzo's death.
Additionally, Van Dine's rules only apply throughout the course of the game's timeline between the intro post and the inevitable end.
Kinzo is alive.
Kinzo is in Kuwadorian.
Battler did not solve the riddle [first].
There are 7 people on the island of Rokkenjima as of the end of GBP4
None of the cousins solved the riddle [first].
[Virgilia's Disciple was] the detective.
You [had] 48 hours to deconstruct and solve my mystery.
Maria was in the Cousin's Room until the death of Kyrie.
The culprit is on the island.
The body identified as Shannon has no name, it has had no name since before the start of the game.
Natsuhi was outside the VIP Room until the second twilight.
The new Kinzo is alive. The old one is, indeed, dead.
None of the husbands solved the riddle.
Kyrie was killed from close-range but not point-blank.
"Ange" was never presumed dead until she was found as she was on the Game Board.
Kanon certainly was there.
Virgilia does not represent Eva.
Gaap does not represent a physical thing.
Stakes have nothing to do with murder weapons.
The Red Witch is not Natsuhi.
The Blue Witch is not Eva.
KYRIE is not Rosa.
Ange represents a living human being.
Natsuhi never left the VIP Room following her death.
No-one - living or dead - has entered or exited a room through use of a window.
The culprit did, indeed, lock the window from the inside.
The bed was placed in its position by the culprit.
At least one version of Beatrice does not represent a killer.
Since well before the first twilight, all of the keys have been in the garden shed. Since they've been placed in the garden shed, the garden shed door has not once been unlocked.
And for the record, yes, the garden shed door was locked.
Like I said, ALL of the keys are in the garden shed.
All of the keys.
All of them.
None of them left the garden shed since well before the first twilight.
Doors must be locked with the door closed. The doors were not locked from the inside.
No-one who actually checked the VIP Room's door lied about whether or not it was locked.
The role of detective pertains to the body's eyes rather than their mind.
Virgilia was not Rosa.
No-one killed Shannon.
Shannon did not commit suicide.
Shannon did not die in an accident.
Shannon does not exist on the island.
With the exception of Kanon, none of the servants left the kitchen between the time they were instructed to go to the kitchen to when they followed the Ushiromiya party to Kuwadorian.
The corpse was definitely there.
The corpse also once belonged to a living breathing human.
Since the death of the living breathing human, the body has since lost its name.
There are meta characters that represent things other than people.
The corpse belongs to someone mentioned at the start of the story.
No corpses have been reused.
Jessica died on the first twilight.
The corpse of "Shannon" was a dead corpse.
Maria is alive
Natsuhi never left the VIP Room after she was killed.
The former name of the corpse was mentioned during this game's intro.
Jessica never left the cousin's room after she was killed.
He died on the first twilight and remained in the cousins' room ever since his death.
Mammon is not Kyrie.
The corpse of "Shannon" was not once known as Kinzo.
No stakes physically caused the death of anyone.
Natsuhi died in the VIP Room.
None of the tools in the garden shed have been used.
The one who solved the epitaph other than Eva is alive.
Natsuhi was killed and stayed in the VIP Room until the end of the game.
The corpse of "Shannon" has not once been known as either Kyrie or Asumu.
Rosa was not the first to find "Shannon."
There are more than 2 killers.
Since Battler and Kanon laid eyes on the keys, which by the way, was all of the keys, not one was removed from the garden shed.
The corpse lost its name before its face and clothes were changed.
EVA is not Eva.
"Shannon's" corpse has never been known as Beatrice.
"Shannon's" corpse doesn't share a name with another person on the island, afterall, the corpse has no name has had no name since it died.
Maria did not solve the riddle.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has been seen by the detective throughout the course of this game.
If someone other than the original corpse has the name OF the original corpse, the original corpse no longer has the name. In other words, no two people have the same name. (In addendum, I am referring only to their bodies.)
No-one other than Battler, Eva, Maria and Yasu survived the massacre - that's not even considering the possibility of Battler and Eva's deaths.
Natsuhi did not fake her death.
Mammon does not represent the culprit that killed Kyrie.
The person who took the corpse's name did so on purpose but not with the intent to trick anyone.
Natsuhi was killed on the second twilight. The only time, through the duration of the game (being defined as between the first twilight to the last game board phase,) Natsuhi has ONLY been killed on the second twilight.
The corpse never belonged to any outside of the Ushiromiya family.
The body of Kinzo that died before the game does not exist on the island.
Eva did not touch the body.
Kinzo is alive and survived the massacre.
Goldsmith is not a person.
Eva, Battler and Maria all had only one personality.
The body was originally placed in the VIP Room.
Neither Kyrie nor Rosa placed the body in the VIP Room.
Krauss was NOT the first to discover the now unnamed corpse.
The Red Witch does not represent an alternate personality.
Goldsmith does NOT represent a person!
Mammon has nothing to do with Battler and Kyrie.
Gaap does not represent moving bodies nor the locking of the keys.
The Red Witch does not represent Eva.
Mammon does not represent a state of mind.
I'm gonna have to ask you to expand on the "culprit's efforts."
The Red Witch has nothing to do with Natsuhi.
Kyrie did not touch the corpse.
I've already stated that no room has been locked from the inside.
The door to the Guest House was also reported to be locked.
The Guest House door was not locked from the inside either.
However, the corpse was discovered in the VIP Room by the person that moved it to where it was discovered by everyone else, before the deaths of Rudolf, Hideyoshi and Krauss.
A key is necessary to lock the Guest House door with mortal methods.
Yasu did not move the corpse to where it was discovered by everyone else.
Neither the culprit nor Yasu was in the Guest House at this point in time.
Krauss did not kill Natsuhi. Krauss truly loved her.
Krauss did not kill anyone.
Mammon does not represent the culprit that killed Kyrie.
Battler did not kill Kyrie.
None of the husbands helped anyone move "Shannon."
Eva was not even on the same floor at the time of the murders of the husbands.
Krauss did not show Genji Natsuhi's corpse.
Mammon has nothing to do with an aspect of Kyrie's personality.
The bodies of the husbands were dead only AFTER the body of Shannon was discovered by someone other than the person that placed her there, for the first time.
The person who killed the husbands did not kill the original Natsuhi.
Krauss did not show Genji anyone's corpse.
Following the departure of the husbands, the first person to leave the study was Eva.
Rosa was not the first person to discover the corpse of "Shannon," aside from the person that placed it there.
Final blue is ineffective.
Yasu placed the body in the VIP Room to begin with, Yasu IS the exception already noted.
Eva was moved after the murder of the husbands.
Kyrie did not kill anyone.
Mammon does not represent an inanimate object.
Yasu did not place the body downstairs.
Yasu was not the first person to discover the body in the VIP Room, with the exception of the person that placed it there as Yasu IS the one that placed it there.
None of the servants killed the husbands.
None of the husbands killed anyone.
Eva did not kill the husbands.
The detective heard gunshots, however, if Eva, Kyrie, Rosa and Battler were in the study as the Game Board Narrative states they were, they would not have heard the gunshots.
The men were killed in the VIP Room.
Rosa, Kyrie, Battler, Eva, Krauss, Hideyoshi and Rudolf all entered the study. The men, excluding Battler left in a group and, afterwards, so did the others.
Battler didn't kill the men.
The men were killed before anyone tried to enter the VIP Room. The one who killed the men killed Jessica and George and "drugged" Maria.
Rosa left the study at the same time as everyone else.
The one now known as Natsuhi did not kill the one FORMERLY known as Natsuhi.
Eva did not "pretend" to find anything.
Kyrie and Battler were not the first to discover the bodies.
The only opportunity for anyone within the group of Kyrie, Eva, Rosa and Battler is when everyone was outside the study. But if anyone fired a gun inside with everyone in the mansion, everyone would have heard.
The men were killed through a gunshot.
The study is the only soundproofed room inside the mansion.
The men were killed in the VIP Room.
The detective was inside.
The detective heard gunshots.
No one would have ignored nor pretended not to hear a gunshot.
Did you not see Ebil's alibi? Eva was in bed during the first twilight.
The killer of the cousins is the killer of the men.
If Eva didn't kill the cousins then I can guarantee that Eva did not kill the men.
Eva didn't kill the cousins.
Eva's body did not kill the cousins.
The men were killed BEFORE the party left for the Guest House (and later, the vault.)
Eva did not kill Kyrie.
Kyrie was killed where she was found.
KYRIE does not represent Eva.
The Red Witch represents a murderer.
Battler did not save Eva from Rosa.
The Red Witch does not represent Shannon.
Battler couldn't have finished Rosa off because he was lying on the ground, drunk, like the lightweight he is.
Battler was already unconscious when Rosa died.
Erika didn't kill anyone.
Rosa wasn't crazy.
Mammon has nothing to do with either Kyrie nor being an accomplice.
Leviathan does not represent only Kyrie's envy.
Leviathan represents more than Kyrie's emotions.
Mammon does not represent a sin.
Mammon does not represent killing intent.
Mammon represents neither a gun nor an action.
Mammon has nothing to do with hesitation nor love.
Rosa died of a gunshot.
Mammon has nothing to do with motive or desire.
Mammon does not represent a state of mind nor anger.
Mammon does not represent Rosa.
"After what [Natsuhi] had done, [Yasu] can forgive, but at the same time [Yasu] must thank [Natsuhi] for giving [them] the chance to find love in another form... in a much more splendid form... The love [they] know is sacred and even if [they]'ve had to find another way to receive it, it is true. [They] guarantee it."
The culprit did not escape the shed using the window.
Natsuhi is not a victim.
Maria, George and Jessica are in the cousins' room.
The keys in the shed are the keys from the servants' room.
The paint [used on the doors] is from the garden shed.
There is a living breathing person still within the cousins' room as we speak.
The room the first victims are in has been sealed with a chain lock.
This chain lock has been sealed by the culprit.
Shannon is dead.
However, Shannon was not murdered.
Shannon did not commit suicide.
Shannon did not die in an accident.
Eva has no possession of any key whatsoever.
The window of the cousins' room has been closed and locked from the inside.
There are absolutely no accomplices.
The body in the VIP Room as of this moment is the real body of Natsuhi.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has appeared in front of the detective.
The culprit has moved bodies.
Natsuhi's body is still holding all her limbs. Quite nicely actually, very little leakage if you ask me. Fine craftsmanship.
The servants heard several things, why else would they be in the kitchen?
The servants found in the kitchen did not leave the kitchen during the murders of the men.
Before any questions are asked - yes, the servants found in the kitchen were in the kitchen to begin with during the murders of the men. This includes Nanjo.
Drugs - defined as a medicinal or intoxicating item considered neither food nor drink - have not been used at all during the course of this game.
At the start of this game there were exactly 20 people. Now, there are 13 people on the island of Rokkenjima.
Shannon has no corpse.
Natsuhi is not Beatrice.
Please, I demand you define the term "The Other Beatrice."
Kinzo does not represent anyone, he is a person.
Sakutarou does not represent George.
Everything else may stand.
Eva was not the first to solve the Riddle.
Rosa has not solved the riddle.
As of this moment, the stakes as they appeared during the fight scene do not have anything to do with neither a cause of death nor a murder weapon.
This is a story about the bond between mothers and their children.
Rosa: "I love my daughter, Maria so much. I would never harm her like this, maybe I ruined her image of me, maybe I looked like a black witch to her, but I would kill to ensure her happiness..."
Eva: "George... I never should have pushed you as much as I did. I truly loved you... I never would have wanted something like this to happen to you."
Kyrie: "Battler... I have never loved you and I truly wish you died instead of my own child 18 years ago."
The killer has not once been in disguise
As of the end of Turn Three GB, there are 8 people on the island of Rokkenjima.
The dead body identified as Shannon was not Kinzo.
The detective certainly did lay eyes on the keys in the shed.
Kyrie's death was not faked.
You have far more than three possible people to suspect to be the detective.
The body identified as the corpse of Shannon was not one of the servants in disguise.
Kyrie's cause of death was not killed by a stab wound.
The servants, with the exception of Kanon, are all dead.
There is one detective in every game, this player will live until the end of the game. Everything that is seen and observed by the detective is regarded as absolute and indisputable truth, the detective may be revealed by the GM. The Detective cannot be the true culprit.
I have provided the perspectives of more than 3 people:
Shannon
Kanon
Beatrice
Rosa
Eva
Natsuhi
Krauss
Sakutarou
Kyrie
There was a corpse in Shannon's clothing.
Kyrie was not killed from the outside.
Kanon is not a servant anymore. It has been stated for a very long time that his employed - Kinzo - is dead. I am of course referring to the original Kinzo Ushiromiya whose death was revealed at the start of this game. Until the death of Krauss, the only servant was Gohda, having been employed by him.
The corpse [identified as Shannon] was not one of the cousins.
I have already stated outright that Battler is not the only person who can be detective.
Rosa has been with the group whenever Battler has investigated crime scenes, her perspective doesn't need to be shown, it just needs to be said that everything Battler has seen, Rosa has seen also.
The detective is in Kuwadorian and they did hear the gunshot that killed Kyrie.
The servants have not upheld duties of a servant as evidenced by their disregard of bringing canned food to the family and their tailing of the party to Kuwadorian.
The corpse is Shannon's Clothes was a real body which really was dead. However, since before the beginning of this game, the body has lost its name.
Nanjo was seen by the detective outside the cousins room (the chained room where Jessica's body was seen) during the investigation of the first twilight (the time period where the survivors attempted and failed to get into the room and the garden shed).
Hideyoshi, Krauss and Rudolf are dead. Their corpses are in the VIP Room.
They all died in the second game board phase.
Krauss was sleeping peacefully in his room at the time of the murders.
Battler fell asleep in the parlour exactly as he said to Shannon. Whilst he was awake and waiting before falling asleep he was engrossed in a murder mystery story known as "Higurashi no Naku Koro Ni.
Eva was also asleep during the first twilight.
Natsuhi was in the VIP Room during all twilights from 2 onwards (as of this meta phase and with the possible exception of her own death as it occurred on the game board)
Natsuhi is dead.
Mammon has nothing to do with Natsuhi.
Eva was conscious as of current events depicted within the game board.
Eva is not wounded.
Someone solved the riddle before Eva. This was not Rosa however.
"Ange" is not one of the cousins.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has been seen by the detective throughout the course of this game.
Natsuhi was not stabbed to death.
The black witch has not solved the riddle.
Mammon is not a murder weapon.
Natsuhi was seen by the detective after the first twilight.
Natsuhi did not die of injuries.
Natsuhi was not poisoned.
The culprit did not solve the riddle.
The corpse of "Shannon" has no name. The corpse lost it's name before the start of the game.
Natsuhi is still Natsuhi.
The body in Shannon's clothes has lost it's entire name. It once had a name but upon the body's death, it's name has been moved.
Natsuhi did not solve the riddle.
The bomb has not gone off.
Natsuhi appeared in front of the detective before the second twilight.
I'd like to note that actions prior to the first twilight do not have be caused by the culprit i.e Kinzo's death.
Additionally, Van Dine's rules only apply throughout the course of the game's timeline between the intro post and the inevitable end.
Kinzo is alive.
Kinzo is in Kuwadorian.
Battler did not solve the riddle [first].
There are 7 people on the island of Rokkenjima as of the end of GBP4
None of the cousins solved the riddle [first].
[Virgilia's Disciple was] the detective.
You [had] 48 hours to deconstruct and solve my mystery.
Maria was in the Cousin's Room until the death of Kyrie.
The culprit is on the island.
The body identified as Shannon has no name, it has had no name since before the start of the game.
Natsuhi was outside the VIP Room until the second twilight.
The new Kinzo is alive. The old one is, indeed, dead.
None of the husbands solved the riddle.
Kyrie was killed from close-range but not point-blank.
"Ange" was never presumed dead until she was found as she was on the Game Board.
Kanon certainly was there.
Virgilia does not represent Eva.
Gaap does not represent a physical thing.
Stakes have nothing to do with murder weapons.
The Red Witch is not Natsuhi.
The Blue Witch is not Eva.
KYRIE is not Rosa.
Ange represents a living human being.
Natsuhi never left the VIP Room following her death.
No-one - living or dead - has entered or exited a room through use of a window.
The culprit did, indeed, lock the window from the inside.
The bed was placed in its position by the culprit.
At least one version of Beatrice does not represent a killer.
Since well before the first twilight, all of the keys have been in the garden shed. Since they've been placed in the garden shed, the garden shed door has not once been unlocked.
And for the record, yes, the garden shed door was locked.
Like I said, ALL of the keys are in the garden shed.
All of the keys.
All of them.
None of them left the garden shed since well before the first twilight.
Doors must be locked with the door closed. The doors were not locked from the inside.
No-one who actually checked the VIP Room's door lied about whether or not it was locked.
The role of detective pertains to the body's eyes rather than their mind.
Virgilia was not Rosa.
No-one killed Shannon.
Shannon did not commit suicide.
Shannon did not die in an accident.
Shannon does not exist on the island.
With the exception of Kanon, none of the servants left the kitchen between the time they were instructed to go to the kitchen to when they followed the Ushiromiya party to Kuwadorian.
The corpse was definitely there.
The corpse also once belonged to a living breathing human.
Since the death of the living breathing human, the body has since lost its name.
There are meta characters that represent things other than people.
The corpse belongs to someone mentioned at the start of the story.
No corpses have been reused.
Jessica died on the first twilight.
The corpse of "Shannon" was a dead corpse.
Maria is alive
Natsuhi never left the VIP Room after she was killed.
The former name of the corpse was mentioned during this game's intro.
Jessica never left the cousin's room after she was killed.
He died on the first twilight and remained in the cousins' room ever since his death.
Mammon is not Kyrie.
The corpse of "Shannon" was not once known as Kinzo.
No stakes physically caused the death of anyone.
Natsuhi died in the VIP Room.
None of the tools in the garden shed have been used.
The one who solved the epitaph other than Eva is alive.
Natsuhi was killed and stayed in the VIP Room until the end of the game.
The corpse of "Shannon" has not once been known as either Kyrie or Asumu.
Rosa was not the first to find "Shannon."
There are more than 2 killers.
Since Battler and Kanon laid eyes on the keys, which by the way, was all of the keys, not one was removed from the garden shed.
The corpse lost its name before its face and clothes were changed.
EVA is not Eva.
"Shannon's" corpse has never been known as Beatrice.
"Shannon's" corpse doesn't share a name with another person on the island, afterall, the corpse has no name has had no name since it died.
Maria did not solve the riddle.
Natsuhi's living and breathing body has been seen by the detective throughout the course of this game.
If someone other than the original corpse has the name OF the original corpse, the original corpse no longer has the name. In other words, no two people have the same name. (In addendum, I am referring only to their bodies.)
No-one other than Battler, Eva, Maria and Yasu survived the massacre - that's not even considering the possibility of Battler and Eva's deaths.
Natsuhi did not fake her death.
Mammon does not represent the culprit that killed Kyrie.
The person who took the corpse's name did so on purpose but not with the intent to trick anyone.
Natsuhi was killed on the second twilight. The only time, through the duration of the game (being defined as between the first twilight to the last game board phase,) Natsuhi has ONLY been killed on the second twilight.
The corpse never belonged to any outside of the Ushiromiya family.
The body of Kinzo that died before the game does not exist on the island.
Eva did not touch the body.
Kinzo is alive and survived the massacre.
Goldsmith is not a person.
Eva, Battler and Maria all had only one personality.
The body was originally placed in the VIP Room.
Neither Kyrie nor Rosa placed the body in the VIP Room.
Krauss was NOT the first to discover the now unnamed corpse.
The Red Witch does not represent an alternate personality.
Goldsmith does NOT represent a person!
Mammon has nothing to do with Battler and Kyrie.
Gaap does not represent moving bodies nor the locking of the keys.
The Red Witch does not represent Eva.
Mammon does not represent a state of mind.
I'm gonna have to ask you to expand on the "culprit's efforts."
The Red Witch has nothing to do with Natsuhi.
Kyrie did not touch the corpse.
I've already stated that no room has been locked from the inside.
The door to the Guest House was also reported to be locked.
The Guest House door was not locked from the inside either.
However, the corpse was discovered in the VIP Room by the person that moved it to where it was discovered by everyone else, before the deaths of Rudolf, Hideyoshi and Krauss.
A key is necessary to lock the Guest House door with mortal methods.
Yasu did not move the corpse to where it was discovered by everyone else.
Neither the culprit nor Yasu was in the Guest House at this point in time.
Krauss did not kill Natsuhi. Krauss truly loved her.
Krauss did not kill anyone.
Mammon does not represent the culprit that killed Kyrie.
Battler did not kill Kyrie.
None of the husbands helped anyone move "Shannon."
Eva was not even on the same floor at the time of the murders of the husbands.
Krauss did not show Genji Natsuhi's corpse.
Mammon has nothing to do with an aspect of Kyrie's personality.
The bodies of the husbands were dead only AFTER the body of Shannon was discovered by someone other than the person that placed her there, for the first time.
The person who killed the husbands did not kill the original Natsuhi.
Krauss did not show Genji anyone's corpse.
Following the departure of the husbands, the first person to leave the study was Eva.
Rosa was not the first person to discover the corpse of "Shannon," aside from the person that placed it there.
Final blue is ineffective.
Yasu placed the body in the VIP Room to begin with, Yasu IS the exception already noted.
Eva was moved after the murder of the husbands.
Kyrie did not kill anyone.
Mammon does not represent an inanimate object.
Yasu did not place the body downstairs.
Yasu was not the first person to discover the body in the VIP Room, with the exception of the person that placed it there as Yasu IS the one that placed it there.
None of the servants killed the husbands.
None of the husbands killed anyone.
Eva did not kill the husbands.
The detective heard gunshots, however, if Eva, Kyrie, Rosa and Battler were in the study as the Game Board Narrative states they were, they would not have heard the gunshots.
The men were killed in the VIP Room.
Rosa, Kyrie, Battler, Eva, Krauss, Hideyoshi and Rudolf all entered the study. The men, excluding Battler left in a group and, afterwards, so did the others.
Battler didn't kill the men.
The men were killed before anyone tried to enter the VIP Room. The one who killed the men killed Jessica and George and "drugged" Maria.
Rosa left the study at the same time as everyone else.
The one now known as Natsuhi did not kill the one FORMERLY known as Natsuhi.
Eva did not "pretend" to find anything.
Kyrie and Battler were not the first to discover the bodies.
The only opportunity for anyone within the group of Kyrie, Eva, Rosa and Battler is when everyone was outside the study. But if anyone fired a gun inside with everyone in the mansion, everyone would have heard.
The men were killed through a gunshot.
The study is the only soundproofed room inside the mansion.
The men were killed in the VIP Room.
The detective was inside.
The detective heard gunshots.
No one would have ignored nor pretended not to hear a gunshot.
Did you not see Ebil's alibi? Eva was in bed during the first twilight.
The killer of the cousins is the killer of the men.
If Eva didn't kill the cousins then I can guarantee that Eva did not kill the men.
Eva didn't kill the cousins.
Eva's body did not kill the cousins.
The men were killed BEFORE the party left for the Guest House (and later, the vault.)
Eva did not kill Kyrie.
Kyrie was killed where she was found.
KYRIE does not represent Eva.
The Red Witch represents a murderer.
Battler did not save Eva from Rosa.
The Red Witch does not represent Shannon.
Battler couldn't have finished Rosa off because he was lying on the ground, drunk, like the lightweight he is.
Battler was already unconscious when Rosa died.
Erika didn't kill anyone.
Rosa wasn't crazy.
Mammon has nothing to do with either Kyrie nor being an accomplice.
Leviathan does not represent only Kyrie's envy.
Leviathan represents more than Kyrie's emotions.
Mammon does not represent a sin.
Mammon does not represent killing intent.
Mammon represents neither a gun nor an action.
Mammon has nothing to do with hesitation nor love.
Rosa died of a gunshot.
Mammon has nothing to do with motive or desire.
Mammon does not represent a state of mind nor anger.
Mammon does not represent Rosa.
"After what [Natsuhi] had done, [Yasu] can forgive, but at the same time [Yasu] must thank [Natsuhi] for giving [them] the chance to find love in another form... in a much more splendid form... The love [they] know is sacred and even if [they]'ve had to find another way to receive it, it is true. [They] guarantee it."