Red Text Archive
Sept 6, 2013 18:00:31 GMT 12
Post by Cloud on Sept 6, 2013 18:00:31 GMT 12
Game One: Legend of the Golden Witch
There are no more than 18 people on the island.
There are no teacups in the dining room that the pot of tea was found.
The only time Eva Ushiromiya was outside during the storm was when she moved back out to the guesthouse
The bodies were found in a locked room, with the doors and windows locked (and the windows locked from the inside). There are no visible forms of attack on the corpses, aside from Shannon's post-mortem wounds
The only way locks can be unlocked is through use of a key
There were no cups inside the dining room where the murders take place and there weren't any visible wounds on the victims (again, aside from Shannon's post-mortem ones)
The storm is still raging, and in this instance, it always will until the one truth has been discovered. In otherwords the storm will continue until the seagulls cry... and when they seagulls cry...There are no survivors.
The faces are not obscured to hide the method of killing.
The same person who served it is the same person who made it. The person who made the tea did not consume the tea. If the tea were poisoned then making the tea would be considered the same as stabbing them, ergo, according to the poison tea theory the one making the tea is not the accomplice but the killer."The Maid" is also one of those inside the garden shed.
Eva and Hideyoshi were together the entire time.
Eva and Hideyoshi went to bed before tea was prepared.
Genji and Kumasawa were in the guest house the entire night
Eva knows the solution to the riddle we were given at the start because Krauss, Rudolf, and Rosa were among the first victims.
Nanjo was with Genji and Kumasawa
If there was a fight in the dining room, those in the guest house would have heard it.
Kanon, like Kumasawa, Genji and Nanjo, was not in the mansion that night. The only servants on duty at the times of the murder were Shannon and Gohda.
There are no duplicate keys. Regardless of whether or not Kanon is lying, the red truth does not lie! Kanon was not present inside the mansion or outside at the time of the murders.
The murders did not occur in the guest house
There are 5 master keys, one to each servant. The only rooms the master keys cannot open are the study and the chapel. Since the beginning of this tale however, not a single servant has used their master key nor lost possession of it.
the detective cannot be an accomplice. Everything important that he sees I will relay so therefore if he assisted with the murders, I would have shown him supporting the murders.
Battler Ushiromiya, the detective, is not the murderer nor an accomplice. However, the only people in the mansion at the time of the murders were the six victims Shannon, Gohda, Kyrie, Rudolf, Rosa, Krauss and Natsuhi.
Yes, the servant's quarters are in the guest house.
Anyone who isn't the detective is considered a suspect.
Everything seen by The Detective is the equivalent to red truth, the damage made to her was shown to have been the caused by tools falling onto her.
Shannon was killed
Natsuhi did not leave the mansion until the discovery of the corpses.
The body found in the garden shed really was not Kinzo's
Kinzo is definitely not in the study, Eva and Natsuhi checked, even without detective's authority I will confirm this for you.
the title of Kinzo also applies to Eva now
Shannon was not killed by the storm, Shannon was killed by another person. Shannon is not an accomplice to murder.
Kumasawa has not harmed a single soul!
Kinzo did not make claw marks anywhere.
Natsuhi did not step foot outside.
the destroyed faces of the first victims was not made to obscure the real cause of death but this does not mean that the cause of death was not obscured when the faces were destroyed for other reasons.
There are no secret entrances! The only entrance was the door locked with a chain
There are no extra personalities controlled by Yasu, there are no more than 18 people on this island
George was, in fact, present at Eva and Hideyoshi's room. He did not kill Kanon.
George, Maria and Jessica were all in the guest house. Regardless of whether or not Yasu is in play, Shannon was in the mansion
Kinzo Ushiromiya is dead before all games.
No silencers are used
The blood [of Eva and Hideyoshi] is human's blood.
The chain lock is on the inside of the room.
Any form of exit through use of the window is impossible, the floor is made of stone and there are no trees nearby, the window is on the second floor.
The deaths of Eva and Hideyoshi Ushiromiya whose bodies were discovered are guaranteed.
The only form of possible entrance is through the door.
The shed was supposed to be locked.
It is only unlocked when tools are in use.
When the shed was unlocked using the normal key, Nanjo and Hideyoshi stepped inside to identify and confirm the deaths of the corpses.
The shed is relatively small but large enough to fit numerous gardening tools.
From the time the chain was broken to the moment everyone else arrived, Genji did not lose sight of the door.
No traps have been used through the course of this game.
Through the course of this game, no-one has entered or exited through a window.
Eva and Hideyoshi were not poisoned, there was no poison in their blood.
Nanjo confirmed their death by checking their pulse and for their breath, they were cold.
Of all deceased bodies, not a single one committed suicide. Every dead body had their free will right up until death.
Suicide is defined as an action in which it causes the death of the body that engaged in the action, even if it is an accident.
The shed has been neither destroyed nor rebuilt.
The floor is concrete.
Dead or alive, the bodies entered through the door and all deceased corpses are still there.
A key is required to lock a door.
A key WAS required, IS required and WILL CONTINUE to require a key in order to be both locked AND unlocked.
The only keys that could have opened the doors are the respective room keys found in the servant's room or the servants' master keys. This game began with only 5 master keys, one for each servant. There has never been, is not and never will be a sixth master key.
There are no other entrances into the study than the door!
[Nanjo's Diagnosis of Eva and Hideyoshi] was correct
No-one has lost their free will.
No door has been moved off its hinges or deconstructed in any way.
When a servant has entered a room, the exit does not lose their line of sight until the moment they close and lock the door.
The one who mutilates is the one who murders and the one who murders, murders them all.
The shed door is a sliding garage door, the guest bedroom is a normal door.
A culprit is defined as one who kills.
An Accomplice is one who allows the culprit to kill.
The one who moved [prior to third game board phase] the bodies is the one who killed the bodies.
As of [the second meta phase], the two remaining servants, Kumasawa and genji have relinquished their keys to Natsuhi. Previously all master keys were in the hands of the servants and the study key was with genji. Now Natsuhi has two master keys and the study key.
Genji did not harm Eva or Hideyoshi in any way, shape or form.
Shannon's body was unrecognisable.
Shannon's body was in the shed
The soundproofing can not block the sound of gunfire or explosion completely. However it does stop the guest house from hearing the sound.
Gohda did not assist with the harming of anyone. Gohda's body is in the shed. The only servants that died were the only servants in the mansion.
Gohda prepared the pot of tea.
Nanjo has not harmed anybody. Nanjo was not in the mansion at the time of the initial murders
Shannon's body did not leave the premise when Nanjo observed her body and confirmed her death.
Gohda prepared the tea himself, no-one else touched the tea.
Gohda served the tea as well
The delivery of the tea spurred the discovery of their corpses.
It was not a fake corpse, Shannon's body was really there.
[Eva and Hideyoshi's] murderer killed them after the chain was set.
Shannon is dead in the shed
No-one who was confirmed to be dead previously was in Eva and Hideyoshi's room at any point in time.
The deaths of everyone are guaranteed!
Not a single key has been unwillingly taken from a servant!
Even though the master keys have never left possession of the servants, this does not apply to the study key.
Game Two: Turn of the Golden Witch
There are no more than 18 people on the island.
With the exception of Yasu, there is at least one person with more than one personality.
Someone has discovered the gold before Maria.
From the time the letter was given to Maria to the time Rosa took the key from the letter, the envelope was not touched.
The envelope was not touched by anyone or anything living or otherwise with the exception of the contents of Maria's bag.
The key did not leave the envelope in the time between Maria being handed the envelope and Rosa's retrieval of the key.
There are no secret entrances or exits to the Chapel.
No-one, dead or alive, entered nor exited through use of a window.
Dead or alive, the victims entered the chapel through the front and only door.
The candy was not involved in the murders.
The meals were placed BEFORE the victims were killed.
None of the dead assisted with their own deaths.
No doors were removed from their hinges.
Maria was aware of her receiving the letter, but not aware of the consequences of possessing the letter.
There never was nor ever will be a secret entrance or exit to or from the chapel.
In this instance, people refers to living persons.
Rosa took the key only once.
The victims saw their meals.
The culprit was in the same room as the victims when the victims died.
There was no poisonous gas used.
The door does not automatically lock itself like the study. The key is necessary to lock the door.
No-one but a servant cooked the meals the victims ate.
Maria did not so much as see the chapel key.
At this point in time, Maria has not even SEEN any key let alone stolen one.
Maria did not touch the envelope after she received it.
Maria WAS given an envelope from Beatrice in front of Rosa.
There are no more than 18 people on the island at the start of the game.
If we subtract the newly deceased we get no more than 12 people.
Doors can only be unlocked through use of a key.
The key to the servant's room... is in the servant's room and was not touched during the course of this game.
In this game, the term "person" does in fact equal "body" with the exception that they are a LIVING body. Personalities are not coined amongst these values. Ergo there are no more than 12 living bodies on this island!
There is only one key that can unlock the chapel and the chapel was unlocked with a key, ergo, the chapel door was opened with the chapel key. Additionally, all doors in the mansion can only be locked and unlocked through use of their respective key or master key with the exception of the Study and Chapel which cannot be unlocked with a master key.
Prior to the murders, the chapel door was locked, following them the door was locked again and unlocked when Rosa discovered the corpses.
The siblings were not "called to" the chapel.
There are no more than 12 people on the island but if we subtract Kinzo, there are only 11 people on the island of Rokkenjima.Kanon gave Jessica his master key to unlock her door.
The chapel's table is in fact the altar.
Nanjo checked the bodies and found there were no injuries other than the stomach holes and Battler acknowledged them himself for guarantee.
The door was in fact locked by the murderer, this rule applies to both the first twilight and the second twilight.
All forms of evidence pertaining to bloodied clothing has been disposed of.
Rosa did not touch the envelope given to Maria by Beatrice at least not until she retrieved the chapel key to discover the bodies.
Rosa did not already have the chapel key when she touched Maria's envelope.
Maria did not know what was in the envelope.
Rosa does not have multiple personalties.
The chapel was locked until after the envelopes were given to Maria and rosa.
The only lock that doesn't require a key to become locked is the study.
The victims died from other causes
Rosa never once touched Maria's envelope until after the murders.
There are no lockpicks involved.
The only way to unlock or lock a door is through use of a key.
The door was successfully locked and unlocked without any form of obstruction, be it through use of silly putty, poor architecture or otherwise.
Beatrice does not fart.
The person who Rosa shot certainly was Beatrice.
Gohda's murder occurred AFTER the Beatrice shooting.
The killer was outside of the chapel before the bodies were discovered.
There are no traps whatsoever.
In this universe, a witch is not a human, they are physically formless and omniscient within the confines of the island. At the start of every game there are no more than 17 bodies on the island.
Denying the possibility of magic within this game requires denial of witches themselves. Admitting the existence of a witch in this game is the equivalent to surrender.
Maria's envelope was not opened until after the murders.
The seal of Maria's envelope was not broken until after the murders.
The key was in its sealed envelope before the murders. Maria's envelope was not broken until the discovery of the bodies.
The envelope Maria received was placed into Maria's bag.
Shannon and Kanon were not seen and diagnosed as dead but their bodies did in fact die.
Anyone could have taken Maria's bag before the Chapel murders.
The key was in an envelope within Maria's bag.
There was a letter in the chapel, of the letters given to Maria and Rosa, one was placed in the Chapel. Additionally this letter was placed there without knowledge of the original recipient that their letter was placed there.
The envelope given to Maria and placed in Maria's bag was not opened until the morning.
The person that sealed Jessica's corpse in her room is THE EXACT SAME person that killed her!
Rosa Ushiromiya ensured my resurrection, the rebirth of Beatrice The Golden Witch and all evidence that stated otherwise was destroyed. Now the only truth that remains to all others that this tale had intrigued is that Beatrice The Golden committed these murders and her existence is guaranteed!
Game Three: Banquet of the Golden Witch
Kinzo's been dead since before the game started, and his body's burnt to a crisp.
Yasu Ushiromiya does not exist.
The keys really were where they were found before and at the time of their discovery.
Jessica is not a murderer.
The only time that someone has left the dining room is when ALL of them left the dining room... This of course includes Eva! *wink wink, nudge nudge* Kihihihihi!
There is no killer that has more than one accomplice. Please note that an accomplice is one who ALLOWS murder to occur but does not directly commit.
George is not a murderer.
If the killer smoked, they would not have lost one on Kyrie's body.
Even if Nanjo was an accomplice, the first 6 truly are dead.
Eva DID, in fact, leave the guest house!
I am afraid you are wrong... Until the discovery of the bodies, NO-ONE BUT Eva and the victims left.
Maria and Rosa were definitely killed and were dead since before they were found. No living person was already in the mansion before the victims entered.
The victims are definitely dead.
Eva would kill them if she had to.
There are no killers with an accomplice that does not kill, in other words, none of the killers have accomplices.
Until the discovery of the victims, none of the children left their room, they were all in the same room together.
Living or dead, there are 18 bodies including Kinzo.
11 of these bodies are dead.
Nanjo is not a murderer
The final body Jessica tripped over was in the parlour after she fled out of the entrance hall.
It is indeed true that Jessica is the detective of this game.
There were a total of four gunshots in the entrance hall and four in the parlour. In this final game board phase there was one shot in the entrance hall and two shots in the parlour.
Battler and Eva were both in the parlour when the first and second gunshots were fired. This includes the shot that killed Nanjo. Battler did not leave the parlour until the end of the game.
Krauss and Natsuhi WERE killed simultaneously. In fact, they were poisoned... by coffee... delivered by Eva!
Eva found the coffee herself, since she found the coffee it never left her sight until she left to deliver the coffee she made.
At the time of the first murders:
In the parlour is a master key and the 2nd floor guest room key. - Shannon
In the 2nd floor guest room is a master key and the 3rd floor waiting room key. - Kumasawa
In the 3rd floor waiting room is a master key and the 2nd floor VIP Room Key. - Gohda
In the 2nd floor VIP Room key is a master key and the boiler room key. - Genji
In the boiler room is the study key and the chapel key. - Kinzo
In the chapel is a master key and the parlour key. - Kanon
If someone attempted to tamper with the coffee she made for Krauss and Natsuhi, Eva would have noticed.
The victims were killed where they were found.
Additionally, the one who found the keys was Eva!
Natsuhi DID take the study key... but this key was later taken by Eva.
None of the first victims were drugged.
The doors were closed before being locked.
Eva took the key BEFORE the murders!
Maria did not steal anyone's keys.
After the siblings argument, there was a brief intermission, in this intermission the siblings found the doors with pentagrams on them.
- Eva has no alibi during their intermission!
- It is not stated how long it took to find these doors!
Allow me to elaborate by saying that the guns were in fact taken from the study.
- These guns were taken by Eva herself!
- Eva did not lose the key to the study until AFTER the murders!
- After the bodies were discovered by the siblings, Eva took the keys found next to the corpses.
- These keys were left with Eva until Kyrie took them before she was murdered.
In addendum: Natsuhi and Krauss were together when scouting the mansion, Kyrie and Rudolf were together when scouting the mansion and Rosa, Hideyoshi and Nanjo were together when scouting the mansion!
At the time that the siblings were separated in that fashion, with the exception of Eva, no-one held a gun.
Neither Kyrie nor Rudolf killed George.
From the moment they were discovered to the moment Jessica stumbled upon them, they did not move at all.
Kyrie and Rudolf were dead between the moment they were first discovered and when Jessica fell over.
Kyrie and Rudolf could have killed Hideyoshi.
Shannon's corpse did not leave the parlour whatsoever.
Kyrie and Rudolf did not move from the one spot that they were found after they were discovered.
Shannon was neither alive nor moved. She was dead when she was found by the siblings and she certainly stayed dead, unfortunately for poor George. Additionally, George was very very very dead as well.
Also Kyrie and Rudolf were incapable of moving following their discovery on the account that they had a minor case of death.
Eva left the guest house between the moment when Kyrie, Hideyoshi and Rudolf left and the moments of their deaths! She also inspected the corpses!
Eva took the Keys from Kyrie's corpse! She later locked the Parlour door during the final confrontation with Battler! Eva unlocked the parlour door after her gun was fired in said parlour!
Battler was not killed in the storm.
No-one would have seen Eva slit Rudolf and Kyrie's throats as there was a window of opportunity do so in which the party turned away to leave for the Guest House.
There was an intermission before the smelling of the blood. In this time all siblings aside from Eva were together.
I can confirm that all siblings and their partners, with the exception of Eva, were together during the murders.
Hideyoshi was with Kyrie, Rudolf, Rosa, Krauss and Natsuhi at the time of the murders.
The cigarette was not removed from Hideyoshi's deceased corpse.
The coffee was indeed poisoned whilst Eva was in the kitchen, however, when the coffee was poisoned Eva saw the poison being placed into the coffee and did not dispute it!
Battler Ushiromiya did not murder Rudolf and Kyrie.
Battler did not "attempt" to murder Eva.
Battler was not poisoned.
Hideyoshi did not stay with Eva at all times.
Jessica was not killed posthumously.
The one who killed Jessica was fully aware of what they were doing.
The murderer of Jessica was unmarked, standing on two feet above Jessica.
The murderer of Jessica aimed their gun at Jessica's head and fired the gun, knowingly and completely obliterating Jessica's life.
The gun used to kill Jessica was Eva's gun.
George was killed by another human being holding a gun to him at point blank range and firing.
Kyrie and Rudolf were dead at the time of George's death.
George was not killed by Battler.
One killer is still alive at the end of the game.
It has already been stated that Nanjo is not a murderer.
Nanjo is dead.
Jessica fell on a body in the parlour!
When I state "at the end of the game" I am referring to Jessica's death. Therefore there still is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident!
The body Jessica tripped over was a corpse from inside the parlour.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident! The previous victim of the murderer is within the parlour. Jessica tripped over the corpse of the second-last victim!
Battler was not killed in a struggle with Nanjo. The second last victim was killed in a struggle with Eva. There are no accidents, they were murdered.
The one shot by Eva's gun in the parlour did not kill Jessica.
There are no goddamn suicides! Who do you think I am? Shannon-chan?
The second last victim was neither Nanjo nor Jessica.
With the exception of Eva, Battler was killed by no-one.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident.
Jessica's cause of death was someone standing on their two feet aiming a gun at her head and pulling the trigger, killing her instantly.
Battler did not die after Jessica was killed.
The servants were killed in the rooms they were found in.
Rosa did not move after her impalement
Natsuhi and Krauss were not in the rose garden when Rosa and Maria... were "incapacitated."
Eva only has one personality, the exception to this rule is the title of Kinzo, but that is a title not a personality.
None of the siblings, with the exception of Eva, none of the children nor Nanjo attempted endangerment of Rosa and/or Maria's lives.
Edit Report
Bakura136
Also, let me confuse you a little bit more. The second last victim that was killed in the parlour did not kill anybody during the course of this game. This person is neither Jessica nor Nanjo.
Before the death of Nanjo, the only living people were Jessica, Nanjo, Battler and Eva.
At the end of the game only one of them is alive.
The person that is alive at the end of the game is the murderer of at least the previous three victims.
The one who murdered Jessica was not injured in the slightest.
The one who murdered Jessica not only murdered the two victims before her but also murdered Krauss and Natsuhi.
The murderer of at least the previous five victims is the survivor of the Rokkenjima incident.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima Incident.
The corpse Jessica tripped over truly was dead.
The corpse Jessica tripped over was the second last victim, in other words, Jessica was killed after the corpse she tripped over was killed.
The corpse that Jessica tripped over was killed in a struggle with Eva.
Jessica saw their bodies.
Nanjo confirmed their deaths.
Rosa did not kill Maria
Maria did not kill Rosa
Nanjo did not kill Rosa or Maria
George did not kill Rosa or Maria
Jessica did not kill Rosa or Maria
Shannon did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kumasawa did not kill Rosa or Maria
Gohda did not kill Rosa or Maria
Genji did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kinzo did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kanon did not kill Rosa or Maria
The siblings, with the exception of Eva, were in the bar with Nanjo. - in this case the siblings ASIDE from the victims and Eva were in the bar.
Nanjo is not an accomplice.
Eva was being taken care of by Hideyoshi.
Rosa and Maria were killed before they were searched for.
Battler did not kill Rosa or Maria.
All the siblings, with the exception of Eva and Rosa, were in the bar. Their respective partners were also in the bar with them. Nanjo was in the bar. These people did not commit the murders of Rosa and/or Maria.
Hideyoshi did not smoke until he left with Kyrie and Rudolf.
Eva did not incapacitate Rosa and Maria without killing them.
Rosa and Maria were not actually incapacitated without dying at all.
Rudolf and Kyrie were not both killed by Hideyoshi.
Natsuhi and Krauss were not strangled.
Eva did not once lose sight of the poisoned coffee, even when it was being poisoned.
The second last victim was killed inside the parlour.
Nanjo was the THIRD last victim, ergo, killed BEFORE the murder in the parlour.
Natsuhi and Krauss were murdered by POISON.
The coffee was poisoned whilst being served.
Eva and Battler were under each other's surveillance until the second last death in the parlour.
EVA PUT THE POISON IN THE COFFEE!
Nanjo was killed in the entrance hall, not the parlour.
Battler was in the parlour when Nanjo was shot.
NO-ONE BESIDES BATTLER, EVA, NANJO AND JESSICA WERE ALIVE IN THE MANSION AT THE TIME!!!!!!!
EVA HELD HER OWN GUN DURING NANJO'S DEATH!
Battler didn't kill Rudolf and Kyrie.
The gun that was used to kill Nanjo was Eva's gun. This gun was in Eva's hands when it was fired by the killer to kill Nanjo.
The gun was aimed at Nanjo before being fired. He was killed intentionally by the killer as the gun was in Eva's hands.
There certainly was a way to stop it hitting Nanjo.
The killers were Hideyoshi Ushiromiya, Rosa Ushiromiya, Rudolf Ushiromiya, Kyrie Ushiromiya, Natsuhi Ushiromiya, Krauss Ushiromiya, and Battler Ushiromiya! They were fueled by greed, as each group wanted the gold for themselves and were willing to kill anybody that stood in their way.
Game Four: Alliance of the Golden Witch
12 living persons on the island right now.
Those killed in the dining room were not drugged and were killed by none other than Kinzo. Those killed in the dining room witnessed and acknowledged Kinzo as Kinzo and they were killed by Kinzo. The missing persons were not drugged.
The title of Kinzo is passed down to the first person to solve the Riddle of the Epitaph.
The Kinzo that was acknowledged in the Dining Room was not "the Heir."
Krauss did in fact claim headship! Whoops!
Kyrie was not the first to solve the epitaph.
The title of Kinzo was not changed via solving the riddle.
Kyrie didn't think she was the first to solve the riddle.
The servants were unable to do anything to stop the murders, this is literally a matter of pathetic incompetence on their part. Typical furniture.
No-one would mistake anything for Kinzo other than Kinzo himself.
Gohda and Kumasawa suck, the mackerel would have a greater chance of killing than them!
So no they didn't do jack shit.
Battler heard everything Jessica said on the phone. He was in room at the time.
The Kinzo that killed the first six victims was very much alive and not a stuffed person.
The Kinzo that killed George, Jessica, Kanon and Shannon is the same person that killed the first six people.
Battler did not hear any gunshots.
Ebil has been revived as Kyrie Ushiromiya.
Shannon was not present within the dining room when the murders occurred, she was not in the mansion at all in fact.
Gohda and Kumasawa are already dead.
Aside from Yasu, there is at least one person with multiple personalities.
The key to the garden shed, all the master keys and Gohda and Kumasawa are inside the garden shed which is locked.
Battler didn't hear any gunshots over the phone, even though the phone was not hung up during Kyrie's supposed death.
The one who gained the title of Kinzo is dead.
The title of the Kinzo that killed those in the dining room was given to someone before the riddle was solved.
Gohda and Kumasawa were murdered after the shed was closed.
They were killed from inside.
The murderer is so horribly aware.
No-one would mistake Kinzo for anyone other than Kinzo himself.
Kumasawa and Gohda were dead before Battler's test.
Jessica is not an accomplice, Krauss has not harmed a single soul.
Eventually all answers will point to Kinzo.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not in the guest house when Battler was on the phone with Jessica or Kyrie.
Maria left on her own accord.
No-one has been knocked out in any shape or form without resulting in death.
No-one was poisoned.
Neither Battler nor Yasu solved the riddle of the epitaph first.
Natsuhi did not harm a soul. Natsuhi is dead.
The title of Kinzo that the murderer has was given to them before the initial murders.
The Riddle of the Epitaph was solved before the first set of murders.
The one who solved the riddle did not kill anyone.
No murders occurred in the study. The murders I have stated that occur in the dining room, certainly happened in the dining room.
Krauss is not an accomplice.
The title of Kinzo is passed down to the first person to solve the Riddle of the Epitaph, yet the title of Kinzo was not changed via solving the riddle.
Kyrie was not in the dining room when the initial murders occurred.
The Kinzo that killed George, Jessica, Kanon and Shannon is the same person that killed the first six people.
The victims of the first twilight are all dead.
The person who found the gold claimed headship successfully before dying.
The culprit had already escaped.
The culprit did not leave the conference until everyone was dead.
The culprits gun was already hidden when Battler came.
The culprit that killed everyone so far did so under the same persona.
Ninjas is on every drug known to man and some known only to fish.
every single one of the people involved in the first twilight is dead.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not involved in the disappearance of Maria.
The garden shed door is locked from the outside.
Kanon 's body is missing, but he is dead too.
Battler Ushiromiya, aside from Kinzo Ushiromiya, you are the only person who exists on the island. And yet, you are about to die. Obviously, you are going to kill yourself but regardless you are going to be killed.
You have 48 hours to solve my mystery.
With the exception of Kinzo Ushiromiya, everyone is dead.
Yasu is dead.
Battler, being the only living person in the family, would make him the new Kinzo but he is not Kinzo Ushiromiya.
The killer killed everyone under the same name. The name of the killer and the title of Kinzo go hand in hand.
With everyone dead except for Kinzo, Battler inherits the title of Kinzo.
The Kinzo that killed is not the Kinzo with multiple personalities.
The one who had the personality of Kinzo did not kill anyone and they most certainly are dead.
Krauss or Natsuhi solved the riddle first.
Natsuhi does not hold the personality of GOLDSMITH, don't be ridiculous.
NATSUHI DID NOT HAVE THE SPLIT PERSONALITY
No-one disguised themselves as Kinzo.
Kinzo's corpse was not discovered
What a shame that this hypothetical head would have been killed by the culprit.
Each one of the victims died instantly.
No evidence would have been found if Battler entered the dining room earlier.
Like I said, [Gohda and Kumasawa] were killed from the inside [Of the Garden Shed.]
Krauss was not in the dining room when the initial murders occurred. He was not in the mansion at all in fact.
At least two of the four people stated above were not accomplices.
The vanished pieces from the first twilight did indeed leave on their own accord.
Nanjo is not an accomplice.
Krauss and Kyrie were not in the dining room when the initial murders occured
Shannon wasn't in the dining room at that time either HOWEVER She and Krauss were the only two not in the mansion at all
Krauss already found the gold during the first murders.
Kyrie didn't touch a gun.
Krauss had found the gold when the murders occurred.
Kyrie was not in the mansion at the time of the initial murders.
7 is the incorrect number of dead people. (On the first twilight)
Yasu was murdered before Battler talked to Beatrice.
The storm drowned out the sounds of most of the gunfire but regardless, Battler heard four gunshots, this added to his despair.
There were murders that occurred in the dining room.
At the end of the game, including Kinzo Ushiromiya, there are 17 dead bodies!
Jessica's death was not faked.
Erika, being dead before the start of this game, is not considered a body on the island. (Also tag your spoilers she hasn't been implemented yet.)
Yasu was not the last to die before Battler died.
Battler was murdered.
Yasu was not the last person alive on Rokkenjima, Battler was, the second last person to die also was not Beatrice.
Battler saw the corpses of everyone, no-one faked their deaths.
Even if Battler mistook their corpses for something else, I can guarantee right now that, with the exception of the possibility of Kinzo Ushiromiya, Battler Ushiromiya is the only living body on Rokkenjima as of 11:59pm of October 5.
Battler saw Krauss some time after midnight, it definitely wasn't an instinctual decision to search the area where his corpse was, Krauss was found approximately 1:30-2:00am of October 5
Krauss Ushiromiya certainly, without a doubt, is DEAD
Maria did not struggle at all.
No-one aside from the 7 bodies in the dining room were killed in the dining room.
There was only one bullet hole in each victim.
Nothing other than their respective gunshot wounds created the corpses.
Any struggle that occurred ended in death.
Until 12:00am of October 6, no wound on their body aside from their single gunshot wounds existed on their body.
The state of the bodies were not changed between the time of their murder and their discovery.
Neither Maria's murder, nor Maria herself, caused the additional amount of blood.
There was a change between the Battler's discovery of the letter and his discovery of the corpses themselves.
The killer was not trying to create a scenario in which a struggle occurred.
Other than the victims, no-one was injured without dying in the dining room. Anyone injured in any other room would have died in the room that they were injured, no-one injured in a room other than the dining room went through the dining room.
The cause of Maria's death was not hidden by excessive blood.
Neither items nor location of the culprit's position were obscured by the blood.
Nothing on the victims was intentionally hidden by excess blood.
The culprit was not hiding amongst the corpses.
None of the corpses were dragged into the dining room.
None of the corpses were moved.
The culprit was not washing the blood off of themselves.
Rest assured however... All of Neptune's ocean could not cleanse their hands.
No-one faked their own deaths.
The culprit didn't hide anything relevant to their identity with blood.
Nothing was moved from the dining room.
Other than blood, nothing was placed in the dining room.
The method of murder was not obscured by the blood.
Nothing relevant to the location of the gold was hidden by the blood.
The added blood does not belong to anyone in the dining room.
The added blood does not belong to anyone who died in the mansion.
The blood DOES NOT belong to one or more of the bodies found outside the garden shed.
Everyone died where they were found.
The first murders did not take place in the study.
The murders that took place in the dining room occurred after the grandchildren were taken to the guest house.
Those found in the dining room were killed in the dining room.
Krauss was not killed in the vault.
I acknowledge it; George died before Jessica.
Gohda and Kumasawa entered the Garden Shed without the culprit entering alongside them.
No-one has faked their own deaths.
Battler was not supposed to find the letter, the letter stated that one must no stay outside if they're not taking their test. Krauss' body was not moved from where it was shot.
The two females mentioned by Rosa were neither Kyrie nor Yasu.
Kumasawa cannot be an accomplice without Gohda being one as well
Kyrie is not a murderer and not a willing accomplice.
There is only one murderer.
The women mentioned by Rosa was neither Natsuhi nor Eva.
Although undiscovered by Rosa, there was also a female underneath the table.
Maria Ushiromiya really died.
The voice questionably assumed to be Kyrie was actually Kyrie.
There is only one person aside from Yasu with multiple personalities.
Maria's test did not take place in the dining room.
Rosa did not describe either Kyrie or Shannon.
The gap was not caused by the culprit moving the gold.
Maria's test took place in the study.
Maria was already dead when she was found.
Rosa was not referring to herself.
The bodies of all the siblings, their partners and the servants, that means Krauss, Natsuhi, Eva, Hideyoshi, Rudolf, Kyrie, Rosa, Yasu, Genji, Kumasawa, Gohda and Nanjo are ALL innocent of murder. None have personalities that have committed murder either. Additionally they are all truly dead and were dead when they were discovered by Battler.
If one chooses to ignore the existence of Kinzo Ushiromiya, as of 11:59pm of October 5, Battler's body is the only body that is functioning. However, at 12:00am of October 6, Battler was killed but not by his own hands.
Maria was certainly told to go to the dining room by the culprit.
And of course someone on the island was disguised as Beatrice but they are DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD!
In the same way that Battler received the title of Kinzo when the Kinzo before him had died, i.e when everyone was killed, Battler was certainly given the title of head, Jessica inherited the name of Kinzo when Krauss died, being his next of Kin.
Jessica, George and Maria were all under Battler's surveillance until he himself left for the dining room when Gohda and Kumasawa entered and recounted the scenario. In the time in which Battler entered the dining room, no murders were committed.
Jessica WAS Kinzo!
Maria never once held a single demon stake.
Those killed in the dining room witnessed and acknowledged Kinzo as Kinzo and they were killed by Kinzo. The missing persons were not drugged.
As you yourself know, at 10:30pm 2 bodies ceased functioning!
Maria's death was not faked by anyone.
Additionally let it be known that if Jessica died, which I can confirm that she did, the title of Kinzo would be passed to the next in line, this would be Eva, after her is George, after him is Rudolf, then Battler, then Rosa then Maria.
Krauss was not killed at 10:30.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not killed by a trap.
If the siblings are dead, the title would fall on their children.
If Jessica died, AND ONCE AGAIN I CONFIRM THAT JESSICA DID DIE, the title would fall on Eva, but if Eva was dead it would fall on George!
GEORGE DID NOT DIE AT 10:30PM!!!
The culprit killed Jessica
Jessica was not killed at 10:30
George was part of the first 6 victims killed at 10:00pm. As was Krauss.
Kinzo created the horrific murders of Rokkenjima on October 4-6 1986. Jessica was simply a fool played by her own hand. She may have created the catbox but it was Kinzo Ushiromiya that became the truth.
Game Five - Forgery of the Golden Witch
Turn One:
Five bodies ceased functioning at 3:30 am on October 5th, 1986.
The victims were all called out individually to the location where they were killed.
Natsuhi's room is on the second floor.
Natsuhi's door was locked, she said so herself.
Natsuhi claimed she was in the bathroom, when she came out she found the bodies.
Erika Furudo is the detective.
Eva, Shannon and Battler do not have alibis that acquit them of murder.
No clue may be used to solve the mystery that has not been revealed to the reader. Any evidence used to support claims must have been witnessed on the gameboard or revealed publicly
Shannon is not the culprit.
I can state that no-one, dead or alive, has entered or exited through a window at this point in time.
"This point in time" refers to all events prior to the end of the game board phase.
None of the master keys were used on Natsuhi's door between 3am and 10am.
The corpses were not hidden in Natsuhi's room before being arranged in the way that they were found.
If Natsuhi left through her bedroom door, she definitely would have locked it behind her.
During investigation of the crime scene, no-one was found hiding.
The bodies were moved to Natsuhi's room after Natsuhi woke up.
Turn Two:
One body ceased functioning at 10:30am on October 5th.
Shannon was killed where she was found, there was plenty of blood beneath her that had seeped into the carpets.
The blood in the sink was there because of the culprit, indeed.
The conversation was not staged. However, being from a subjective perspective we do not know if a conversation even happened.
Of course [Battler, George and Maria returned to the parlour after leaving the trolley in the kitchen]! George did not lie!
Battler, George and Maria had no blood on them at all.
Natsuhi is the Satoko Houjou of the Umineko franchise!
Battler, George and Maria did not change into spare clothes after the murder, at the very least, not clothes they could change into before Natsuhi's discovery.
The keys on Genji and Krauss weren't always on their persons from the moment of their death to the discovery of the keys by Erika.
Until the discovery of the smear after Shannon's murder, no-one entered the bathroom except for Natsuhi!
It was definitely blood!
With the exception of those already absent, no-one left the parlour during the murder of Shannon
No-one entered the bathroom before Natsuhi!
There is only one murderer.
Eva Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Rudolf Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Rosa Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Battler has immunity so he cannot be killed until the end of the game
The door was locked at the moment that Natsuhi screamed, Natsuhi unlocked the door herself with the key that was already on her person!
This means that no-one could have used the key that Krauss had!
Natsuhi has to be awake to commit murder.
Natsuhi's door WAS locked [on the night of the murderers.]
None of the master keys were used.
Kinzo's guns are all in order as told by Erika's observations!
Nothing in the guest bedroom has been shown to have been able to pose threat to Natsuhi in the future, that breaks Knox's Eighth (It is forbidden for the case to be resolved with clues that are not presented!)
The duct tape seals would detect entry into the study and/or second guest bedroom!
Turn Three:
One bullet from Rosa's gun has been used.
At 11:30am on October 5th, 1986, one body ceased functioning.
At 3:30pm on October 5th, 1986, two bodies have ceased functioning.
It is possible for the door to be unlocked from the inside without a master key!
Eva Ushiromiya is neither an accomplice nor a killer.
Maria is not an accomplice as none of the keys on Eva's person were stolen.
There is a key that could have unlocked the second floor guest bedroom!
The party approached the parlour at approximately 10:00am and Shannon was killed at 10:30, Natsuhi discovered her body 10 minutes later!
There is more than one servant's quarters! One in the mansion and one in the guest house!
Prior to Shannon's death, the party with the exception of Erika entered both servants' quarters!
No-one other than Battler, George and Maria left the parlour alongside Shannon. If anyone else had left, Erika would have seen it.
Kinzo was already dead.
The tape of Erika only applies to the rooms, at any rate, the information we are given is at Erika's discretion, Natsuhi's tape around her being broken is valid!
The flaw in Eva and Shannon's alibi is the fact that they were alone when their partners left and did in fact gain a small understanding of where their partners were going. Battler's flaw was the fact that he saw Jessica leave. If Battler left with George aware of him leaving, George would be known as an accomplice, however George is not an accomplice to murder. George is not a murderer either and Eva is not an accomplice.
There are no more than 18 people on the island.
There are no teacups in the dining room that the pot of tea was found.
The only time Eva Ushiromiya was outside during the storm was when she moved back out to the guesthouse
The bodies were found in a locked room, with the doors and windows locked (and the windows locked from the inside). There are no visible forms of attack on the corpses, aside from Shannon's post-mortem wounds
The only way locks can be unlocked is through use of a key
There were no cups inside the dining room where the murders take place and there weren't any visible wounds on the victims (again, aside from Shannon's post-mortem ones)
The storm is still raging, and in this instance, it always will until the one truth has been discovered. In otherwords the storm will continue until the seagulls cry... and when they seagulls cry...There are no survivors.
The faces are not obscured to hide the method of killing.
The same person who served it is the same person who made it. The person who made the tea did not consume the tea. If the tea were poisoned then making the tea would be considered the same as stabbing them, ergo, according to the poison tea theory the one making the tea is not the accomplice but the killer."The Maid" is also one of those inside the garden shed.
Eva and Hideyoshi were together the entire time.
Eva and Hideyoshi went to bed before tea was prepared.
Genji and Kumasawa were in the guest house the entire night
Eva knows the solution to the riddle we were given at the start because Krauss, Rudolf, and Rosa were among the first victims.
Nanjo was with Genji and Kumasawa
If there was a fight in the dining room, those in the guest house would have heard it.
Kanon, like Kumasawa, Genji and Nanjo, was not in the mansion that night. The only servants on duty at the times of the murder were Shannon and Gohda.
There are no duplicate keys. Regardless of whether or not Kanon is lying, the red truth does not lie! Kanon was not present inside the mansion or outside at the time of the murders.
The murders did not occur in the guest house
There are 5 master keys, one to each servant. The only rooms the master keys cannot open are the study and the chapel. Since the beginning of this tale however, not a single servant has used their master key nor lost possession of it.
the detective cannot be an accomplice. Everything important that he sees I will relay so therefore if he assisted with the murders, I would have shown him supporting the murders.
Battler Ushiromiya, the detective, is not the murderer nor an accomplice. However, the only people in the mansion at the time of the murders were the six victims Shannon, Gohda, Kyrie, Rudolf, Rosa, Krauss and Natsuhi.
Yes, the servant's quarters are in the guest house.
Anyone who isn't the detective is considered a suspect.
Everything seen by The Detective is the equivalent to red truth, the damage made to her was shown to have been the caused by tools falling onto her.
Shannon was killed
Natsuhi did not leave the mansion until the discovery of the corpses.
The body found in the garden shed really was not Kinzo's
Kinzo is definitely not in the study, Eva and Natsuhi checked, even without detective's authority I will confirm this for you.
the title of Kinzo also applies to Eva now
Shannon was not killed by the storm, Shannon was killed by another person. Shannon is not an accomplice to murder.
Kumasawa has not harmed a single soul!
Kinzo did not make claw marks anywhere.
Natsuhi did not step foot outside.
the destroyed faces of the first victims was not made to obscure the real cause of death but this does not mean that the cause of death was not obscured when the faces were destroyed for other reasons.
There are no secret entrances! The only entrance was the door locked with a chain
There are no extra personalities controlled by Yasu, there are no more than 18 people on this island
George was, in fact, present at Eva and Hideyoshi's room. He did not kill Kanon.
George, Maria and Jessica were all in the guest house. Regardless of whether or not Yasu is in play, Shannon was in the mansion
Kinzo Ushiromiya is dead before all games.
No silencers are used
The blood [of Eva and Hideyoshi] is human's blood.
The chain lock is on the inside of the room.
Any form of exit through use of the window is impossible, the floor is made of stone and there are no trees nearby, the window is on the second floor.
The deaths of Eva and Hideyoshi Ushiromiya whose bodies were discovered are guaranteed.
The only form of possible entrance is through the door.
The shed was supposed to be locked.
It is only unlocked when tools are in use.
When the shed was unlocked using the normal key, Nanjo and Hideyoshi stepped inside to identify and confirm the deaths of the corpses.
The shed is relatively small but large enough to fit numerous gardening tools.
From the time the chain was broken to the moment everyone else arrived, Genji did not lose sight of the door.
No traps have been used through the course of this game.
Through the course of this game, no-one has entered or exited through a window.
Eva and Hideyoshi were not poisoned, there was no poison in their blood.
Nanjo confirmed their death by checking their pulse and for their breath, they were cold.
Of all deceased bodies, not a single one committed suicide. Every dead body had their free will right up until death.
Suicide is defined as an action in which it causes the death of the body that engaged in the action, even if it is an accident.
The shed has been neither destroyed nor rebuilt.
The floor is concrete.
Dead or alive, the bodies entered through the door and all deceased corpses are still there.
A key is required to lock a door.
A key WAS required, IS required and WILL CONTINUE to require a key in order to be both locked AND unlocked.
The only keys that could have opened the doors are the respective room keys found in the servant's room or the servants' master keys. This game began with only 5 master keys, one for each servant. There has never been, is not and never will be a sixth master key.
There are no other entrances into the study than the door!
[Nanjo's Diagnosis of Eva and Hideyoshi] was correct
No-one has lost their free will.
No door has been moved off its hinges or deconstructed in any way.
When a servant has entered a room, the exit does not lose their line of sight until the moment they close and lock the door.
The one who mutilates is the one who murders and the one who murders, murders them all.
The shed door is a sliding garage door, the guest bedroom is a normal door.
A culprit is defined as one who kills.
An Accomplice is one who allows the culprit to kill.
The one who moved [prior to third game board phase] the bodies is the one who killed the bodies.
As of [the second meta phase], the two remaining servants, Kumasawa and genji have relinquished their keys to Natsuhi. Previously all master keys were in the hands of the servants and the study key was with genji. Now Natsuhi has two master keys and the study key.
Genji did not harm Eva or Hideyoshi in any way, shape or form.
Shannon's body was unrecognisable.
Shannon's body was in the shed
The soundproofing can not block the sound of gunfire or explosion completely. However it does stop the guest house from hearing the sound.
Gohda did not assist with the harming of anyone. Gohda's body is in the shed. The only servants that died were the only servants in the mansion.
Gohda prepared the pot of tea.
Nanjo has not harmed anybody. Nanjo was not in the mansion at the time of the initial murders
Shannon's body did not leave the premise when Nanjo observed her body and confirmed her death.
Gohda prepared the tea himself, no-one else touched the tea.
Gohda served the tea as well
The delivery of the tea spurred the discovery of their corpses.
It was not a fake corpse, Shannon's body was really there.
[Eva and Hideyoshi's] murderer killed them after the chain was set.
Shannon is dead in the shed
No-one who was confirmed to be dead previously was in Eva and Hideyoshi's room at any point in time.
The deaths of everyone are guaranteed!
Not a single key has been unwillingly taken from a servant!
Even though the master keys have never left possession of the servants, this does not apply to the study key.
Game Two: Turn of the Golden Witch
There are no more than 18 people on the island.
With the exception of Yasu, there is at least one person with more than one personality.
Someone has discovered the gold before Maria.
From the time the letter was given to Maria to the time Rosa took the key from the letter, the envelope was not touched.
The envelope was not touched by anyone or anything living or otherwise with the exception of the contents of Maria's bag.
The key did not leave the envelope in the time between Maria being handed the envelope and Rosa's retrieval of the key.
There are no secret entrances or exits to the Chapel.
No-one, dead or alive, entered nor exited through use of a window.
Dead or alive, the victims entered the chapel through the front and only door.
The candy was not involved in the murders.
The meals were placed BEFORE the victims were killed.
None of the dead assisted with their own deaths.
No doors were removed from their hinges.
Maria was aware of her receiving the letter, but not aware of the consequences of possessing the letter.
There never was nor ever will be a secret entrance or exit to or from the chapel.
In this instance, people refers to living persons.
Rosa took the key only once.
The victims saw their meals.
The culprit was in the same room as the victims when the victims died.
There was no poisonous gas used.
The door does not automatically lock itself like the study. The key is necessary to lock the door.
No-one but a servant cooked the meals the victims ate.
Maria did not so much as see the chapel key.
At this point in time, Maria has not even SEEN any key let alone stolen one.
Maria did not touch the envelope after she received it.
Maria WAS given an envelope from Beatrice in front of Rosa.
There are no more than 18 people on the island at the start of the game.
If we subtract the newly deceased we get no more than 12 people.
Doors can only be unlocked through use of a key.
The key to the servant's room... is in the servant's room and was not touched during the course of this game.
In this game, the term "person" does in fact equal "body" with the exception that they are a LIVING body. Personalities are not coined amongst these values. Ergo there are no more than 12 living bodies on this island!
There is only one key that can unlock the chapel and the chapel was unlocked with a key, ergo, the chapel door was opened with the chapel key. Additionally, all doors in the mansion can only be locked and unlocked through use of their respective key or master key with the exception of the Study and Chapel which cannot be unlocked with a master key.
Prior to the murders, the chapel door was locked, following them the door was locked again and unlocked when Rosa discovered the corpses.
The siblings were not "called to" the chapel.
There are no more than 12 people on the island but if we subtract Kinzo, there are only 11 people on the island of Rokkenjima.Kanon gave Jessica his master key to unlock her door.
The chapel's table is in fact the altar.
Nanjo checked the bodies and found there were no injuries other than the stomach holes and Battler acknowledged them himself for guarantee.
The door was in fact locked by the murderer, this rule applies to both the first twilight and the second twilight.
All forms of evidence pertaining to bloodied clothing has been disposed of.
Rosa did not touch the envelope given to Maria by Beatrice at least not until she retrieved the chapel key to discover the bodies.
Rosa did not already have the chapel key when she touched Maria's envelope.
Maria did not know what was in the envelope.
Rosa does not have multiple personalties.
The chapel was locked until after the envelopes were given to Maria and rosa.
The only lock that doesn't require a key to become locked is the study.
The victims died from other causes
Rosa never once touched Maria's envelope until after the murders.
There are no lockpicks involved.
The only way to unlock or lock a door is through use of a key.
The door was successfully locked and unlocked without any form of obstruction, be it through use of silly putty, poor architecture or otherwise.
Beatrice does not fart.
The person who Rosa shot certainly was Beatrice.
Gohda's murder occurred AFTER the Beatrice shooting.
The killer was outside of the chapel before the bodies were discovered.
There are no traps whatsoever.
In this universe, a witch is not a human, they are physically formless and omniscient within the confines of the island. At the start of every game there are no more than 17 bodies on the island.
Denying the possibility of magic within this game requires denial of witches themselves. Admitting the existence of a witch in this game is the equivalent to surrender.
Maria's envelope was not opened until after the murders.
The seal of Maria's envelope was not broken until after the murders.
The key was in its sealed envelope before the murders. Maria's envelope was not broken until the discovery of the bodies.
The envelope Maria received was placed into Maria's bag.
Shannon and Kanon were not seen and diagnosed as dead but their bodies did in fact die.
Anyone could have taken Maria's bag before the Chapel murders.
The key was in an envelope within Maria's bag.
There was a letter in the chapel, of the letters given to Maria and Rosa, one was placed in the Chapel. Additionally this letter was placed there without knowledge of the original recipient that their letter was placed there.
The envelope given to Maria and placed in Maria's bag was not opened until the morning.
The person that sealed Jessica's corpse in her room is THE EXACT SAME person that killed her!
Rosa Ushiromiya ensured my resurrection, the rebirth of Beatrice The Golden Witch and all evidence that stated otherwise was destroyed. Now the only truth that remains to all others that this tale had intrigued is that Beatrice The Golden committed these murders and her existence is guaranteed!
Game Three: Banquet of the Golden Witch
Kinzo's been dead since before the game started, and his body's burnt to a crisp.
Yasu Ushiromiya does not exist.
The keys really were where they were found before and at the time of their discovery.
Jessica is not a murderer.
The only time that someone has left the dining room is when ALL of them left the dining room... This of course includes Eva! *wink wink, nudge nudge* Kihihihihi!
There is no killer that has more than one accomplice. Please note that an accomplice is one who ALLOWS murder to occur but does not directly commit.
George is not a murderer.
If the killer smoked, they would not have lost one on Kyrie's body.
Even if Nanjo was an accomplice, the first 6 truly are dead.
Eva DID, in fact, leave the guest house!
I am afraid you are wrong... Until the discovery of the bodies, NO-ONE BUT Eva and the victims left.
Maria and Rosa were definitely killed and were dead since before they were found. No living person was already in the mansion before the victims entered.
The victims are definitely dead.
Eva would kill them if she had to.
There are no killers with an accomplice that does not kill, in other words, none of the killers have accomplices.
Until the discovery of the victims, none of the children left their room, they were all in the same room together.
Living or dead, there are 18 bodies including Kinzo.
11 of these bodies are dead.
Nanjo is not a murderer
The final body Jessica tripped over was in the parlour after she fled out of the entrance hall.
It is indeed true that Jessica is the detective of this game.
There were a total of four gunshots in the entrance hall and four in the parlour. In this final game board phase there was one shot in the entrance hall and two shots in the parlour.
Battler and Eva were both in the parlour when the first and second gunshots were fired. This includes the shot that killed Nanjo. Battler did not leave the parlour until the end of the game.
Krauss and Natsuhi WERE killed simultaneously. In fact, they were poisoned... by coffee... delivered by Eva!
Eva found the coffee herself, since she found the coffee it never left her sight until she left to deliver the coffee she made.
At the time of the first murders:
In the parlour is a master key and the 2nd floor guest room key. - Shannon
In the 2nd floor guest room is a master key and the 3rd floor waiting room key. - Kumasawa
In the 3rd floor waiting room is a master key and the 2nd floor VIP Room Key. - Gohda
In the 2nd floor VIP Room key is a master key and the boiler room key. - Genji
In the boiler room is the study key and the chapel key. - Kinzo
In the chapel is a master key and the parlour key. - Kanon
If someone attempted to tamper with the coffee she made for Krauss and Natsuhi, Eva would have noticed.
The victims were killed where they were found.
Additionally, the one who found the keys was Eva!
Natsuhi DID take the study key... but this key was later taken by Eva.
None of the first victims were drugged.
The doors were closed before being locked.
Eva took the key BEFORE the murders!
Maria did not steal anyone's keys.
After the siblings argument, there was a brief intermission, in this intermission the siblings found the doors with pentagrams on them.
- Eva has no alibi during their intermission!
- It is not stated how long it took to find these doors!
Allow me to elaborate by saying that the guns were in fact taken from the study.
- These guns were taken by Eva herself!
- Eva did not lose the key to the study until AFTER the murders!
- After the bodies were discovered by the siblings, Eva took the keys found next to the corpses.
- These keys were left with Eva until Kyrie took them before she was murdered.
In addendum: Natsuhi and Krauss were together when scouting the mansion, Kyrie and Rudolf were together when scouting the mansion and Rosa, Hideyoshi and Nanjo were together when scouting the mansion!
At the time that the siblings were separated in that fashion, with the exception of Eva, no-one held a gun.
Neither Kyrie nor Rudolf killed George.
From the moment they were discovered to the moment Jessica stumbled upon them, they did not move at all.
Kyrie and Rudolf were dead between the moment they were first discovered and when Jessica fell over.
Kyrie and Rudolf could have killed Hideyoshi.
Shannon's corpse did not leave the parlour whatsoever.
Kyrie and Rudolf did not move from the one spot that they were found after they were discovered.
Shannon was neither alive nor moved. She was dead when she was found by the siblings and she certainly stayed dead, unfortunately for poor George. Additionally, George was very very very dead as well.
Also Kyrie and Rudolf were incapable of moving following their discovery on the account that they had a minor case of death.
Eva left the guest house between the moment when Kyrie, Hideyoshi and Rudolf left and the moments of their deaths! She also inspected the corpses!
Eva took the Keys from Kyrie's corpse! She later locked the Parlour door during the final confrontation with Battler! Eva unlocked the parlour door after her gun was fired in said parlour!
Battler was not killed in the storm.
No-one would have seen Eva slit Rudolf and Kyrie's throats as there was a window of opportunity do so in which the party turned away to leave for the Guest House.
There was an intermission before the smelling of the blood. In this time all siblings aside from Eva were together.
I can confirm that all siblings and their partners, with the exception of Eva, were together during the murders.
Hideyoshi was with Kyrie, Rudolf, Rosa, Krauss and Natsuhi at the time of the murders.
The cigarette was not removed from Hideyoshi's deceased corpse.
The coffee was indeed poisoned whilst Eva was in the kitchen, however, when the coffee was poisoned Eva saw the poison being placed into the coffee and did not dispute it!
Battler Ushiromiya did not murder Rudolf and Kyrie.
Battler did not "attempt" to murder Eva.
Battler was not poisoned.
Hideyoshi did not stay with Eva at all times.
Jessica was not killed posthumously.
The one who killed Jessica was fully aware of what they were doing.
The murderer of Jessica was unmarked, standing on two feet above Jessica.
The murderer of Jessica aimed their gun at Jessica's head and fired the gun, knowingly and completely obliterating Jessica's life.
The gun used to kill Jessica was Eva's gun.
George was killed by another human being holding a gun to him at point blank range and firing.
Kyrie and Rudolf were dead at the time of George's death.
George was not killed by Battler.
One killer is still alive at the end of the game.
It has already been stated that Nanjo is not a murderer.
Nanjo is dead.
Jessica fell on a body in the parlour!
When I state "at the end of the game" I am referring to Jessica's death. Therefore there still is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident!
The body Jessica tripped over was a corpse from inside the parlour.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident! The previous victim of the murderer is within the parlour. Jessica tripped over the corpse of the second-last victim!
Battler was not killed in a struggle with Nanjo. The second last victim was killed in a struggle with Eva. There are no accidents, they were murdered.
The one shot by Eva's gun in the parlour did not kill Jessica.
There are no goddamn suicides! Who do you think I am? Shannon-chan?
The second last victim was neither Nanjo nor Jessica.
With the exception of Eva, Battler was killed by no-one.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima incident.
Jessica's cause of death was someone standing on their two feet aiming a gun at her head and pulling the trigger, killing her instantly.
Battler did not die after Jessica was killed.
The servants were killed in the rooms they were found in.
Rosa did not move after her impalement
Natsuhi and Krauss were not in the rose garden when Rosa and Maria... were "incapacitated."
Eva only has one personality, the exception to this rule is the title of Kinzo, but that is a title not a personality.
None of the siblings, with the exception of Eva, none of the children nor Nanjo attempted endangerment of Rosa and/or Maria's lives.
Edit Report
Bakura136
Also, let me confuse you a little bit more. The second last victim that was killed in the parlour did not kill anybody during the course of this game. This person is neither Jessica nor Nanjo.
Before the death of Nanjo, the only living people were Jessica, Nanjo, Battler and Eva.
At the end of the game only one of them is alive.
The person that is alive at the end of the game is the murderer of at least the previous three victims.
The one who murdered Jessica was not injured in the slightest.
The one who murdered Jessica not only murdered the two victims before her but also murdered Krauss and Natsuhi.
The murderer of at least the previous five victims is the survivor of the Rokkenjima incident.
There is only one survivor of the Rokkenjima Incident.
The corpse Jessica tripped over truly was dead.
The corpse Jessica tripped over was the second last victim, in other words, Jessica was killed after the corpse she tripped over was killed.
The corpse that Jessica tripped over was killed in a struggle with Eva.
Jessica saw their bodies.
Nanjo confirmed their deaths.
Rosa did not kill Maria
Maria did not kill Rosa
Nanjo did not kill Rosa or Maria
George did not kill Rosa or Maria
Jessica did not kill Rosa or Maria
Shannon did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kumasawa did not kill Rosa or Maria
Gohda did not kill Rosa or Maria
Genji did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kinzo did not kill Rosa or Maria
Kanon did not kill Rosa or Maria
The siblings, with the exception of Eva, were in the bar with Nanjo. - in this case the siblings ASIDE from the victims and Eva were in the bar.
Nanjo is not an accomplice.
Eva was being taken care of by Hideyoshi.
Rosa and Maria were killed before they were searched for.
Battler did not kill Rosa or Maria.
All the siblings, with the exception of Eva and Rosa, were in the bar. Their respective partners were also in the bar with them. Nanjo was in the bar. These people did not commit the murders of Rosa and/or Maria.
Hideyoshi did not smoke until he left with Kyrie and Rudolf.
Eva did not incapacitate Rosa and Maria without killing them.
Rosa and Maria were not actually incapacitated without dying at all.
Rudolf and Kyrie were not both killed by Hideyoshi.
Natsuhi and Krauss were not strangled.
Eva did not once lose sight of the poisoned coffee, even when it was being poisoned.
The second last victim was killed inside the parlour.
Nanjo was the THIRD last victim, ergo, killed BEFORE the murder in the parlour.
Natsuhi and Krauss were murdered by POISON.
The coffee was poisoned whilst being served.
Eva and Battler were under each other's surveillance until the second last death in the parlour.
EVA PUT THE POISON IN THE COFFEE!
Nanjo was killed in the entrance hall, not the parlour.
Battler was in the parlour when Nanjo was shot.
NO-ONE BESIDES BATTLER, EVA, NANJO AND JESSICA WERE ALIVE IN THE MANSION AT THE TIME!!!!!!!
EVA HELD HER OWN GUN DURING NANJO'S DEATH!
Battler didn't kill Rudolf and Kyrie.
The gun that was used to kill Nanjo was Eva's gun. This gun was in Eva's hands when it was fired by the killer to kill Nanjo.
The gun was aimed at Nanjo before being fired. He was killed intentionally by the killer as the gun was in Eva's hands.
There certainly was a way to stop it hitting Nanjo.
The killers were Hideyoshi Ushiromiya, Rosa Ushiromiya, Rudolf Ushiromiya, Kyrie Ushiromiya, Natsuhi Ushiromiya, Krauss Ushiromiya, and Battler Ushiromiya! They were fueled by greed, as each group wanted the gold for themselves and were willing to kill anybody that stood in their way.
Game Four: Alliance of the Golden Witch
12 living persons on the island right now.
Those killed in the dining room were not drugged and were killed by none other than Kinzo. Those killed in the dining room witnessed and acknowledged Kinzo as Kinzo and they were killed by Kinzo. The missing persons were not drugged.
The title of Kinzo is passed down to the first person to solve the Riddle of the Epitaph.
The Kinzo that was acknowledged in the Dining Room was not "the Heir."
Krauss did in fact claim headship! Whoops!
Kyrie was not the first to solve the epitaph.
The title of Kinzo was not changed via solving the riddle.
Kyrie didn't think she was the first to solve the riddle.
The servants were unable to do anything to stop the murders, this is literally a matter of pathetic incompetence on their part. Typical furniture.
No-one would mistake anything for Kinzo other than Kinzo himself.
Gohda and Kumasawa suck, the mackerel would have a greater chance of killing than them!
So no they didn't do jack shit.
Battler heard everything Jessica said on the phone. He was in room at the time.
The Kinzo that killed the first six victims was very much alive and not a stuffed person.
The Kinzo that killed George, Jessica, Kanon and Shannon is the same person that killed the first six people.
Battler did not hear any gunshots.
Ebil has been revived as Kyrie Ushiromiya.
Shannon was not present within the dining room when the murders occurred, she was not in the mansion at all in fact.
Gohda and Kumasawa are already dead.
Aside from Yasu, there is at least one person with multiple personalities.
The key to the garden shed, all the master keys and Gohda and Kumasawa are inside the garden shed which is locked.
Battler didn't hear any gunshots over the phone, even though the phone was not hung up during Kyrie's supposed death.
The one who gained the title of Kinzo is dead.
The title of the Kinzo that killed those in the dining room was given to someone before the riddle was solved.
Gohda and Kumasawa were murdered after the shed was closed.
They were killed from inside.
The murderer is so horribly aware.
No-one would mistake Kinzo for anyone other than Kinzo himself.
Kumasawa and Gohda were dead before Battler's test.
Jessica is not an accomplice, Krauss has not harmed a single soul.
Eventually all answers will point to Kinzo.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not in the guest house when Battler was on the phone with Jessica or Kyrie.
Maria left on her own accord.
No-one has been knocked out in any shape or form without resulting in death.
No-one was poisoned.
Neither Battler nor Yasu solved the riddle of the epitaph first.
Natsuhi did not harm a soul. Natsuhi is dead.
The title of Kinzo that the murderer has was given to them before the initial murders.
The Riddle of the Epitaph was solved before the first set of murders.
The one who solved the riddle did not kill anyone.
No murders occurred in the study. The murders I have stated that occur in the dining room, certainly happened in the dining room.
Krauss is not an accomplice.
The title of Kinzo is passed down to the first person to solve the Riddle of the Epitaph, yet the title of Kinzo was not changed via solving the riddle.
Kyrie was not in the dining room when the initial murders occurred.
The Kinzo that killed George, Jessica, Kanon and Shannon is the same person that killed the first six people.
The victims of the first twilight are all dead.
The person who found the gold claimed headship successfully before dying.
The culprit had already escaped.
The culprit did not leave the conference until everyone was dead.
The culprits gun was already hidden when Battler came.
The culprit that killed everyone so far did so under the same persona.
Ninjas is on every drug known to man and some known only to fish.
every single one of the people involved in the first twilight is dead.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not involved in the disappearance of Maria.
The garden shed door is locked from the outside.
Kanon 's body is missing, but he is dead too.
Battler Ushiromiya, aside from Kinzo Ushiromiya, you are the only person who exists on the island. And yet, you are about to die. Obviously, you are going to kill yourself but regardless you are going to be killed.
You have 48 hours to solve my mystery.
With the exception of Kinzo Ushiromiya, everyone is dead.
Yasu is dead.
Battler, being the only living person in the family, would make him the new Kinzo but he is not Kinzo Ushiromiya.
The killer killed everyone under the same name. The name of the killer and the title of Kinzo go hand in hand.
With everyone dead except for Kinzo, Battler inherits the title of Kinzo.
The Kinzo that killed is not the Kinzo with multiple personalities.
The one who had the personality of Kinzo did not kill anyone and they most certainly are dead.
Krauss or Natsuhi solved the riddle first.
Natsuhi does not hold the personality of GOLDSMITH, don't be ridiculous.
NATSUHI DID NOT HAVE THE SPLIT PERSONALITY
No-one disguised themselves as Kinzo.
Kinzo's corpse was not discovered
What a shame that this hypothetical head would have been killed by the culprit.
Each one of the victims died instantly.
No evidence would have been found if Battler entered the dining room earlier.
Like I said, [Gohda and Kumasawa] were killed from the inside [Of the Garden Shed.]
Krauss was not in the dining room when the initial murders occurred. He was not in the mansion at all in fact.
At least two of the four people stated above were not accomplices.
The vanished pieces from the first twilight did indeed leave on their own accord.
Nanjo is not an accomplice.
Krauss and Kyrie were not in the dining room when the initial murders occured
Shannon wasn't in the dining room at that time either HOWEVER She and Krauss were the only two not in the mansion at all
Krauss already found the gold during the first murders.
Kyrie didn't touch a gun.
Krauss had found the gold when the murders occurred.
Kyrie was not in the mansion at the time of the initial murders.
7 is the incorrect number of dead people. (On the first twilight)
Yasu was murdered before Battler talked to Beatrice.
The storm drowned out the sounds of most of the gunfire but regardless, Battler heard four gunshots, this added to his despair.
There were murders that occurred in the dining room.
At the end of the game, including Kinzo Ushiromiya, there are 17 dead bodies!
Jessica's death was not faked.
Erika, being dead before the start of this game, is not considered a body on the island. (Also tag your spoilers she hasn't been implemented yet.)
Yasu was not the last to die before Battler died.
Battler was murdered.
Yasu was not the last person alive on Rokkenjima, Battler was, the second last person to die also was not Beatrice.
Battler saw the corpses of everyone, no-one faked their deaths.
Even if Battler mistook their corpses for something else, I can guarantee right now that, with the exception of the possibility of Kinzo Ushiromiya, Battler Ushiromiya is the only living body on Rokkenjima as of 11:59pm of October 5.
Battler saw Krauss some time after midnight, it definitely wasn't an instinctual decision to search the area where his corpse was, Krauss was found approximately 1:30-2:00am of October 5
Krauss Ushiromiya certainly, without a doubt, is DEAD
Maria did not struggle at all.
No-one aside from the 7 bodies in the dining room were killed in the dining room.
There was only one bullet hole in each victim.
Nothing other than their respective gunshot wounds created the corpses.
Any struggle that occurred ended in death.
Until 12:00am of October 6, no wound on their body aside from their single gunshot wounds existed on their body.
The state of the bodies were not changed between the time of their murder and their discovery.
Neither Maria's murder, nor Maria herself, caused the additional amount of blood.
There was a change between the Battler's discovery of the letter and his discovery of the corpses themselves.
The killer was not trying to create a scenario in which a struggle occurred.
Other than the victims, no-one was injured without dying in the dining room. Anyone injured in any other room would have died in the room that they were injured, no-one injured in a room other than the dining room went through the dining room.
The cause of Maria's death was not hidden by excessive blood.
Neither items nor location of the culprit's position were obscured by the blood.
Nothing on the victims was intentionally hidden by excess blood.
The culprit was not hiding amongst the corpses.
None of the corpses were dragged into the dining room.
None of the corpses were moved.
The culprit was not washing the blood off of themselves.
Rest assured however... All of Neptune's ocean could not cleanse their hands.
No-one faked their own deaths.
The culprit didn't hide anything relevant to their identity with blood.
Nothing was moved from the dining room.
Other than blood, nothing was placed in the dining room.
The method of murder was not obscured by the blood.
Nothing relevant to the location of the gold was hidden by the blood.
The added blood does not belong to anyone in the dining room.
The added blood does not belong to anyone who died in the mansion.
The blood DOES NOT belong to one or more of the bodies found outside the garden shed.
Everyone died where they were found.
The first murders did not take place in the study.
The murders that took place in the dining room occurred after the grandchildren were taken to the guest house.
Those found in the dining room were killed in the dining room.
Krauss was not killed in the vault.
I acknowledge it; George died before Jessica.
Gohda and Kumasawa entered the Garden Shed without the culprit entering alongside them.
No-one has faked their own deaths.
Battler was not supposed to find the letter, the letter stated that one must no stay outside if they're not taking their test. Krauss' body was not moved from where it was shot.
The two females mentioned by Rosa were neither Kyrie nor Yasu.
Kumasawa cannot be an accomplice without Gohda being one as well
Kyrie is not a murderer and not a willing accomplice.
There is only one murderer.
The women mentioned by Rosa was neither Natsuhi nor Eva.
Although undiscovered by Rosa, there was also a female underneath the table.
Maria Ushiromiya really died.
The voice questionably assumed to be Kyrie was actually Kyrie.
There is only one person aside from Yasu with multiple personalities.
Maria's test did not take place in the dining room.
Rosa did not describe either Kyrie or Shannon.
The gap was not caused by the culprit moving the gold.
Maria's test took place in the study.
Maria was already dead when she was found.
Rosa was not referring to herself.
The bodies of all the siblings, their partners and the servants, that means Krauss, Natsuhi, Eva, Hideyoshi, Rudolf, Kyrie, Rosa, Yasu, Genji, Kumasawa, Gohda and Nanjo are ALL innocent of murder. None have personalities that have committed murder either. Additionally they are all truly dead and were dead when they were discovered by Battler.
If one chooses to ignore the existence of Kinzo Ushiromiya, as of 11:59pm of October 5, Battler's body is the only body that is functioning. However, at 12:00am of October 6, Battler was killed but not by his own hands.
Maria was certainly told to go to the dining room by the culprit.
And of course someone on the island was disguised as Beatrice but they are DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD DEAD!
In the same way that Battler received the title of Kinzo when the Kinzo before him had died, i.e when everyone was killed, Battler was certainly given the title of head, Jessica inherited the name of Kinzo when Krauss died, being his next of Kin.
Jessica, George and Maria were all under Battler's surveillance until he himself left for the dining room when Gohda and Kumasawa entered and recounted the scenario. In the time in which Battler entered the dining room, no murders were committed.
Jessica WAS Kinzo!
Maria never once held a single demon stake.
Those killed in the dining room witnessed and acknowledged Kinzo as Kinzo and they were killed by Kinzo. The missing persons were not drugged.
As you yourself know, at 10:30pm 2 bodies ceased functioning!
Maria's death was not faked by anyone.
Additionally let it be known that if Jessica died, which I can confirm that she did, the title of Kinzo would be passed to the next in line, this would be Eva, after her is George, after him is Rudolf, then Battler, then Rosa then Maria.
Krauss was not killed at 10:30.
Gohda and Kumasawa were not killed by a trap.
If the siblings are dead, the title would fall on their children.
If Jessica died, AND ONCE AGAIN I CONFIRM THAT JESSICA DID DIE, the title would fall on Eva, but if Eva was dead it would fall on George!
GEORGE DID NOT DIE AT 10:30PM!!!
The culprit killed Jessica
Jessica was not killed at 10:30
George was part of the first 6 victims killed at 10:00pm. As was Krauss.
Kinzo created the horrific murders of Rokkenjima on October 4-6 1986. Jessica was simply a fool played by her own hand. She may have created the catbox but it was Kinzo Ushiromiya that became the truth.
Game Five - Forgery of the Golden Witch
Turn One:
Five bodies ceased functioning at 3:30 am on October 5th, 1986.
The victims were all called out individually to the location where they were killed.
Natsuhi's room is on the second floor.
Natsuhi's door was locked, she said so herself.
Natsuhi claimed she was in the bathroom, when she came out she found the bodies.
Erika Furudo is the detective.
Eva, Shannon and Battler do not have alibis that acquit them of murder.
No clue may be used to solve the mystery that has not been revealed to the reader. Any evidence used to support claims must have been witnessed on the gameboard or revealed publicly
Shannon is not the culprit.
I can state that no-one, dead or alive, has entered or exited through a window at this point in time.
"This point in time" refers to all events prior to the end of the game board phase.
None of the master keys were used on Natsuhi's door between 3am and 10am.
The corpses were not hidden in Natsuhi's room before being arranged in the way that they were found.
If Natsuhi left through her bedroom door, she definitely would have locked it behind her.
During investigation of the crime scene, no-one was found hiding.
The bodies were moved to Natsuhi's room after Natsuhi woke up.
Turn Two:
One body ceased functioning at 10:30am on October 5th.
Shannon was killed where she was found, there was plenty of blood beneath her that had seeped into the carpets.
The blood in the sink was there because of the culprit, indeed.
The conversation was not staged. However, being from a subjective perspective we do not know if a conversation even happened.
Of course [Battler, George and Maria returned to the parlour after leaving the trolley in the kitchen]! George did not lie!
Battler, George and Maria had no blood on them at all.
Natsuhi is the Satoko Houjou of the Umineko franchise!
Battler, George and Maria did not change into spare clothes after the murder, at the very least, not clothes they could change into before Natsuhi's discovery.
The keys on Genji and Krauss weren't always on their persons from the moment of their death to the discovery of the keys by Erika.
Until the discovery of the smear after Shannon's murder, no-one entered the bathroom except for Natsuhi!
It was definitely blood!
With the exception of those already absent, no-one left the parlour during the murder of Shannon
No-one entered the bathroom before Natsuhi!
There is only one murderer.
Eva Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Rudolf Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Rosa Ushiromiya is not a murderer!
Battler has immunity so he cannot be killed until the end of the game
The door was locked at the moment that Natsuhi screamed, Natsuhi unlocked the door herself with the key that was already on her person!
This means that no-one could have used the key that Krauss had!
Natsuhi has to be awake to commit murder.
Natsuhi's door WAS locked [on the night of the murderers.]
None of the master keys were used.
Kinzo's guns are all in order as told by Erika's observations!
Nothing in the guest bedroom has been shown to have been able to pose threat to Natsuhi in the future, that breaks Knox's Eighth (It is forbidden for the case to be resolved with clues that are not presented!)
The duct tape seals would detect entry into the study and/or second guest bedroom!
Turn Three:
One bullet from Rosa's gun has been used.
At 11:30am on October 5th, 1986, one body ceased functioning.
At 3:30pm on October 5th, 1986, two bodies have ceased functioning.
It is possible for the door to be unlocked from the inside without a master key!
Eva Ushiromiya is neither an accomplice nor a killer.
Maria is not an accomplice as none of the keys on Eva's person were stolen.
There is a key that could have unlocked the second floor guest bedroom!
The party approached the parlour at approximately 10:00am and Shannon was killed at 10:30, Natsuhi discovered her body 10 minutes later!
There is more than one servant's quarters! One in the mansion and one in the guest house!
Prior to Shannon's death, the party with the exception of Erika entered both servants' quarters!
No-one other than Battler, George and Maria left the parlour alongside Shannon. If anyone else had left, Erika would have seen it.
Kinzo was already dead.
The tape of Erika only applies to the rooms, at any rate, the information we are given is at Erika's discretion, Natsuhi's tape around her being broken is valid!
The flaw in Eva and Shannon's alibi is the fact that they were alone when their partners left and did in fact gain a small understanding of where their partners were going. Battler's flaw was the fact that he saw Jessica leave. If Battler left with George aware of him leaving, George would be known as an accomplice, however George is not an accomplice to murder. George is not a murderer either and Eva is not an accomplice.